If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the FAQ by clicking the link above. You may have to register before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below. |
|
|
Thread Tools | Display Modes |
#1
|
|||
|
|||
Fuel injector expected lifespan?
Been lurking here for some time, hoping to absorb the rays of knowledge
emitted by (some) posters (Comboverfish...? This is a Honda problem...). Now I have a problem that is sufficiently obscure as to flummox those I depend on most. The problem is also sufficiently annoying to cause me to crawl out from under that rock over there and post this message over here. The problem seems to have to do with fuel delivery. The car is a 1991 Acura Integra with 266,000 miles on it. The injectors are original. Within the last few weeks, I've had work done on the car to address vibration issues. It turned out the car had three layers of problems: 1) Badly mounted tires. That was fixed. 2) Worn inner CV joints (original). That was fixed. Once the preceding two sources of vibration were eliminated, a third arose: 3) Originally, when accelerating hard from about 3,000 RPM, a fine vibration that is probably better described as a "harshness" arose and more-or-less stayed throughout throughout the engine's remaining rev range. The vibration occured on moderate to heavy acceleration, and stops completely when you lift your foot off the gas (at which point the injectors usually shut off, depending on engine speed). Last weekend I had a Motorvac service done on advice (not from Terry Dyson) that one injector was probably a bit gummed up. Well, the service made the problem WORSE. Now it appears at ANY engine speed. Worse at larger throttle openings, better at smaller. Terry Dyson at Dyson Analysis says the numbers from my last oil analysis show that the engine is likely still in pretty good shape, except that it's getting overfueled (there's gas in the oil). The ignition is all fairly new and makes a nice blue spark, so he surmises that I've got a fuel problem. Again pursuant to the oil test results, Terry Dyson also figures I've got oil control rings that are gummy. It sort of makes sense. I'm now (with the warmer weather) burning a quart of oil in less than 2,000 miles. Yet my soot numbers are very low, suggesting slight blowby. It seems the oil rings are not draining properly, and so oil is getting pumped up into the combustion chamber. So, finally, to my ultimate question: Has any knowledgeable poster ever seen Honda injectors wear unevenly to the point that they inconsistently fuel the engine, or have they ever seen vibration occur from gum and ring deposits? -- TeGGeR® |
Ads |
#2
|
|||
|
|||
Fuel injector expected lifespan?
I would check the pcv system, it might be faulty, leaking / plugged,
creating a contamination problem, the motor supports could be loose - shot, and if you had the flush service done on the injectors / throttle body cleaned, injectors inspected, this is what I would check first. you might need to get a second opinion. mho vƒe >presently, a $1k more / year for gas - based on 12k miles of driving. Get involved. |
#4
|
|||
|
|||
Fuel injector expected lifespan?
how does the under surface of the oil filler cap - look?
what is the primary problem you are trying to overcome, vibration / hesitation? if gasoline is in the oil sump, how did it get there, other than from a leaking fuel injector or bad ignition problems? mho vƒe >presently, a $1k more / year for gas - based on 12k miles of driving. Get involved. |
#5
|
|||
|
|||
Fuel injector expected lifespan?
Are my ears burning? Hey, Tegger!
Thought I'd reply even though I don't have an experience-based answer on your Integra 1.8L specifically. Firstly, if a Motorvac service, all by itself, *did* make a noticeable difference in drivability for the worst, then I would suspect fuel delivery components. This would basically include injectors, regulator, filter, and fuel rail. Realistically, you injectors are what have probably suffered from the dislodging of crap around their pintles into the spray holes at each injector's tip. This will cause a less than ideal spray pattern (important on multi-port injection delivery systems), which will result in unburned gas making it's way into the oil via the piston rings. With 266k on the clock, you can bet that the oil rings are carboned up somewhat -- regardless of how well you cared for the vehicle. This is previous Honda experience talking. If you aren't using a significant amount of oil then I would generally advise you to forgo an expensive overhaul, though. One quart in 2000 miles is not bad for your mileage, but still a borderline call on an overhaul. Regarding your concern about "vibration caused from gum and ring deposits" -- no. The cause and effect from that would be farther apart than, say, linking Kevin Bacon to Nipsey Russell in Six Degrees of Separation. As far as diagnosing injectors is concerned, I feel that they are the last item to consider replacing after all other tests have been made. Some really sharp techs can spot a fuel delivery issue with a scope test of the ignition, but on an engine with your miles it would be difficult to rule out all of the other variables because of worn components skewing the ignition trace. I would first look at the O2 sensor while driving to see if the car was in fuel control. Then I would check the main sensor inputs (MAP, CTS, and TPS) and clean the ground terminal on the thermostat housing. Then I would check compression and leakdown if there was still concern. If everything looked good I might be willing to shotgun a set of injectors. Check out Linder Tech -- www.lindertech.com -- for a quality set of remans. This is basically the only place you can trust short of getting a new set at the dealer. I have never been burned by installing injectors to fix a complaint. I do check everything possible first though, to "eliminate the obvious". It should be mentioned that I rarely replace injectors. It should also be mentioned that I rarely work on a car with 266K Toyota MDT in MO TeGGeR® wrote: > Been lurking here for some time, hoping to absorb the rays of knowledge > emitted by (some) posters (Comboverfish...? This is a Honda problem...). > > Now I have a problem that is sufficiently obscure as to flummox those I > depend on most. The problem is also sufficiently annoying to cause me to > crawl out from under that rock over there and post this message over here. > > The problem seems to have to do with fuel delivery. The car is a 1991 Acura > Integra with 266,000 miles on it. The injectors are original. > > Within the last few weeks, I've had work done on the car to address > vibration issues. It turned out the car had three layers of problems: > 1) Badly mounted tires. That was fixed. > 2) Worn inner CV joints (original). That was fixed. > Once the preceding two sources of vibration were eliminated, a third arose: > 3) Originally, when accelerating hard from about 3,000 RPM, a fine > vibration that is probably better described as a "harshness" arose and > more-or-less stayed throughout throughout the engine's remaining rev range. > > The vibration occured on moderate to heavy acceleration, and stops > completely when you lift your foot off the gas (at which point the > injectors usually shut off, depending on engine speed). > > Last weekend I had a Motorvac service done on advice (not from Terry Dyson) > that one injector was probably a bit gummed up. Well, the service made the > problem WORSE. Now it appears at ANY engine speed. Worse at larger throttle > openings, better at smaller. > > Terry Dyson at Dyson Analysis says the numbers from my last oil analysis > show that the engine is likely still in pretty good shape, except that it's > getting overfueled (there's gas in the oil). The ignition is all fairly new > and makes a nice blue spark, so he surmises that I've got a fuel problem. > > Again pursuant to the oil test results, Terry Dyson also figures I've got > oil control rings that are gummy. It sort of makes sense. I'm now (with the > warmer weather) burning a quart of oil in less than 2,000 miles. Yet my > soot numbers are very low, suggesting slight blowby. It seems the oil rings > are not draining properly, and so oil is getting pumped up into the > combustion chamber. > > So, finally, to my ultimate question: Has any knowledgeable poster ever > seen Honda injectors wear unevenly to the point that they inconsistently > fuel the engine, or have they ever seen vibration occur from gum and ring > deposits? > > > > -- > TeGGeR® |
#6
|
|||
|
|||
Fuel injector expected lifespan?
"TeGGeR®" > wrote in message ... > Been lurking here for some time, hoping to absorb the rays of knowledge > emitted by (some) posters (Comboverfish...? This is a Honda problem...). > > Now I have a problem that is sufficiently obscure as to flummox those I > depend on most. The problem is also sufficiently annoying to cause me to > crawl out from under that rock over there and post this message over here. > > The problem seems to have to do with fuel delivery. The car is a 1991 Acura > Integra with 266,000 miles on it. The injectors are original. > > Within the last few weeks, I've had work done on the car to address > vibration issues. It turned out the car had three layers of problems: > 1) Badly mounted tires. That was fixed. > 2) Worn inner CV joints (original). That was fixed. > Once the preceding two sources of vibration were eliminated, a third arose: > 3) Originally, when accelerating hard from about 3,000 RPM, a fine > vibration that is probably better described as a "harshness" arose and > more-or-less stayed throughout throughout the engine's remaining rev range. > > The vibration occured on moderate to heavy acceleration, and stops > completely when you lift your foot off the gas (at which point the > injectors usually shut off, depending on engine speed). > > Last weekend I had a Motorvac service done on advice (not from Terry Dyson) > that one injector was probably a bit gummed up. Well, the service made the > problem WORSE. Now it appears at ANY engine speed. Worse at larger throttle > openings, better at smaller. > > Terry Dyson at Dyson Analysis says the numbers from my last oil analysis > show that the engine is likely still in pretty good shape, except that it's > getting overfueled (there's gas in the oil). The ignition is all fairly new > and makes a nice blue spark, so he surmises that I've got a fuel problem. > > Again pursuant to the oil test results, Terry Dyson also figures I've got > oil control rings that are gummy. It sort of makes sense. I'm now (with the > warmer weather) burning a quart of oil in less than 2,000 miles. Yet my > soot numbers are very low, suggesting slight blowby. It seems the oil rings > are not draining properly, and so oil is getting pumped up into the > combustion chamber. > > So, finally, to my ultimate question: Has any knowledgeable poster ever > seen Honda injectors wear unevenly to the point that they inconsistently > fuel the engine, or have they ever seen vibration occur from gum and ring > deposits? > > > > -- > TeGGeR® > It should be fairly easy to diagnose the injectors with a pressure drop method. Also check fuel pressure and volume. From the fuel in oil symptom I would suspect either leaky injector or leaking fuel pressure regulator diaphragm. Both are easy to diagnose. -- Kevin Mouton Automotive Technology Instructor "If women don't find you handsome, they should at least find you handy" Red Green |
#7
|
|||
|
|||
Fuel injector expected lifespan?
"Comboverfish" > wrote in
oups.com: > Are my ears burning? Hey, Tegger! > Thought I'd reply even though I don't have an experience-based answer > on your Integra 1.8L specifically. Thanks for the reply. I was hoping you'd answer. > > Firstly, if a Motorvac service, all by itself, *did* make a noticeable > difference in drivability for the worst, then I would suspect fuel > delivery components. This would basically include injectors, > regulator, filter, and fuel rail. Realistically, you injectors are > what have probably suffered from the dislodging of crap around their > pintles into the spray holes at each injector's tip. This will cause > a less than ideal spray pattern (important on multi-port injection > delivery systems), which will result in unburned gas making it's way > into the oil via the piston rings. This certainly makes sense. It happened *immediately* afterwards. The experience was a disaster. The tech didn't hook up at the fuel filter, he did the connections at the fuel pump. In the process, he broke a fuel line, then he wrecked my back seat. The manager refunded my money plus I got $60 of store merchandise for free to make up for it. It makes me wonder what else he messed up. > > As far as diagnosing injectors is concerned, I feel that they are the > last item to consider replacing after all other tests have been made. > Some really sharp techs > can spot a fuel delivery issue with a scope > test of the ignition, but on an engine with your miles it would be > difficult to rule out all of the other variables because of worn > components skewing the ignition trace. I would first look at the O2 > sensor while driving to see if the car was in fuel control. Then I > would check the main sensor inputs (MAP, CTS, and TPS) and clean the > ground terminal on the thermostat housing. Then I would check > compression and leakdown if there was still concern. If everything > looked good I might be willing to shotgun a set of injectors. There is a side issue with a slightly high idle. Sometimes it sits at 800- 850, and takes a while to settle back down to 750. That problem was worse in cold weather. I also had elevated CO in my last emissions test. Still passed, but there's clearly a problem there. > > Check out Linder Tech -- www.lindertech.com -- for a quality set of > remans. This is basically the only place you can trust short of > getting a new set at the dealer. Thanks for the link. I may need that. I'm going to get one more Motorvac done (at a different place) and see what happens. I'm also gettng the fuel filter replaced and the fuel pressure checked tomorrow morning. Thanks again, Comboverfish. -- TeGGeR® |
#8
|
|||
|
|||
Fuel injector expected lifespan?
"Kevin" > wrote in
news:1zD5g.61302$gE.57454@dukeread06: > > "TeGGeR®" > wrote in message > ... >> >> So, finally, to my ultimate question: Has any knowledgeable poster >> ever seen Honda injectors wear unevenly to the point that they >> inconsistently fuel the engine, or have they ever seen vibration >> occur from gum and ring deposits? >> >> >> > > It should be fairly easy to diagnose the injectors with a pressure > drop method. I take it that would be done at the pressure gauge while the engine is running? > Also check fuel pressure and volume. From the fuel in oil > symptom I would suspect either leaky injector or leaking fuel pressure > regulator diaphragm. Both are easy to diagnose. And my regular guy doesn't want to do it, which is bizarre, since he's been wonderful over the last 25 years. I'm getting the pressure and filter looked at tomorrow. I just checked the vacuum line to the fuel pressure regulator right now. There's a slight smell of fuel... -- TeGGeR® The Unofficial Honda/Acura FAQ www.tegger.com/hondafaq/ |
#9
|
|||
|
|||
Fuel injector expected lifespan?
An injector pressure drop test is done with the engine off. First
install a fuel pressure gauge. Then each injector is opened electrically for an exact (short) duration, then the pressure drop is read at the gauge. Finally all pressure drop readings are compared. If there is a difference, you can suspect blockage in the injector or rail area that has the least pressure drop. I take this test with a grain of salt. Maybe I've had bad luck with it, but it hasn't told me much in the past. It's like fixing jewelery with a sledge hammer. I haven't seen a car that showed any significant difference in readings, or maybe my test method was inaccurate. Whatever. You can't use a built in scantool injector pressure drop test on old Hond-Curas, so you would need a specialized injector operator tool, or a timed 12 volt on/off signal. If there really is fuel in the regulator vacuum side, the regulator needs to be replaced. That could be your whole problem. Perhaps the Motorvac tore the (already) weak diaphram. Don't get another Motorvac. Fix the problem first. Toyota MDT in MO TeGGeR® wrote: > "Kevin" > wrote in > news:1zD5g.61302$gE.57454@dukeread06: > > > > > "TeGGeR®" > wrote in message > > ... > > >> > >> So, finally, to my ultimate question: Has any knowledgeable poster > >> ever seen Honda injectors wear unevenly to the point that they > >> inconsistently fuel the engine, or have they ever seen vibration > >> occur from gum and ring deposits? > >> > >> > >> > > > > It should be fairly easy to diagnose the injectors with a pressure > > drop method. > > > > I take it that would be done at the pressure gauge while the engine is > running? > > > > > Also check fuel pressure and volume. From the fuel in oil > > symptom I would suspect either leaky injector or leaking fuel pressure > > regulator diaphragm. Both are easy to diagnose. > > > > And my regular guy doesn't want to do it, which is bizarre, since he's been > wonderful over the last 25 years. > > I'm getting the pressure and filter looked at tomorrow. > > I just checked the vacuum line to the fuel pressure regulator right now. > There's a slight smell of fuel... > > > > -- > TeGGeR® > > The Unofficial Honda/Acura FAQ > www.tegger.com/hondafaq/ |
#10
|
|||
|
|||
Fuel injector expected lifespan?
"Comboverfish" > wrote in
oups.com: > > If there really is fuel in the regulator vacuum side, the regulator > needs to be replaced. That could be your whole problem. Perhaps the > Motorvac tore the (already) weak diaphram. Would you say that there should be NO smell of fuel AT ALL in the vacuum line? There was certainly no liquid in the line. I applied vacuum to the line to see if I could draw liquid out of the regulator. None came out. I've ordered a new regulator anyway. It's $130. The parts guy tells me there is exactly ONE left in all of Canada, and I'm getting it. -- TeGGeR® |
Thread Tools | |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
Ping Tigger: case study on rear O2 sensor and fuel trim | Stephen H | Honda | 0 | December 24th 05 05:37 AM |
Starting Problems | McNick | Jeep | 12 | October 1st 05 03:58 AM |
98 concorde starting problems | xmirage2kx | Chrysler | 90 | August 21st 05 04:32 AM |
Failed Smog Check 1981 Trans AM | TheSmogTech | Technology | 0 | January 30th 05 04:16 PM |
In-the-tank fuel pumps cause death and destruction | Silver Surfer | Chrysler | 293 | November 7th 04 03:41 PM |