If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the FAQ by clicking the link above. You may have to register before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below. |
|
|
Thread Tools | Display Modes |
#1
|
|||
|
|||
328 'grabs' when stopping at slow speed.
I have an N-reg BMW 328 SE Auto. My local garage recently replaced a
broken air hose somewhere which had suddenly started causing stalling (wouldn't idle). And I took the opportunity to have a routine service done, as the 'Inspection' indicators indicated it was due. But now, when stopping at slow speed (e.g. edging forward in traffic), I can no longer brake to a truly smooth halt. At the very last moment, there's a short but sharp 'grab'. Idling is now about 750 rpm instead of the 600 I recall, but I'm assured both by my garage and from replies to a similar post over at uk.rec.cars.maintenance that this is correct. But this definitely makes my car less pleasant to drive. I took it back; mechanic came out with me, acknowledged the behaviour, can't explain it, and says he'll speak to Vines in nearby Crawley. Meanwhile, can anyone suggest a likely cause please? -- Terry, West Sussex, UK |
Ads |
#2
|
|||
|
|||
In ,
Terry Pinnell > typed: > I have an N-reg BMW 328 SE Auto. My local garage recently replaced a > broken air hose somewhere which had suddenly started causing stalling > (wouldn't idle). And I took the opportunity to have a routine service > done, as the 'Inspection' indicators indicated it was due. > > But now, when stopping at slow speed (e.g. edging forward in traffic), > I can no longer brake to a truly smooth halt. At the very last moment, > there's a short but sharp 'grab'. > > Idling is now about 750 rpm instead of the 600 I recall, but I'm > assured both by my garage and from replies to a similar post over at > uk.rec.cars.maintenance that this is correct. But this definitely > makes my car less pleasant to drive. I took it back; mechanic came out > with me, acknowledged the behaviour, can't explain it, and says he'll > speak to Vines in nearby Crawley. Meanwhile, can anyone suggest a > likely cause please? I'd try ACE Automotive near Billingshurst, West Sussex Sorted out my E34 525i a treat. Give Dale a call on 01403 701845 Jason Russell |
#3
|
|||
|
|||
In article >,
Terry Pinnell > wrote: > I have an N-reg BMW 328 SE Auto. My local garage recently replaced a > broken air hose somewhere which had suddenly started causing stalling > (wouldn't idle). And I took the opportunity to have a routine service > done, as the 'Inspection' indicators indicated it was due. > But now, when stopping at slow speed (e.g. edging forward in traffic), > I can no longer brake to a truly smooth halt. At the very last moment, > there's a short but sharp 'grab'. I gave you the likely cause last time you posted this. Why start a new thread? And did you have the check I suggested done? -- *Never test the depth of the water with both feet.* Dave Plowman London SW To e-mail, change noise into sound. |
#4
|
|||
|
|||
"Dave Plowman (News)" > wrote:
>In article >, > Terry Pinnell > wrote: >> I have an N-reg BMW 328 SE Auto. My local garage recently replaced a >> broken air hose somewhere which had suddenly started causing stalling >> (wouldn't idle). And I took the opportunity to have a routine service >> done, as the 'Inspection' indicators indicated it was due. > >> But now, when stopping at slow speed (e.g. edging forward in traffic), >> I can no longer brake to a truly smooth halt. At the very last moment, >> there's a short but sharp 'grab'. > >I gave you the likely cause last time you posted this. Why start a new >thread? And did you have the check I suggested done? Here's your reply from uk.rec.cars.maintenance in full, so others know what we're on about: --------- "Is this the roll out change to first gear? If so, sounds like the idle sensor is out of adjustment - on my 528 if you come to a halt with your foor still on the throttle even slightly - by left foot braking - you'll get a thump into first. Try pulling the throttle *up* with your foot and see if this makes a difference. It might just be cable adjustment - if indeed it has a cable." --------- I wasn't sure I understood some of your points. For a start, what is a 'roll out change to first gear'? The behaviour I described is a short 'grab', as if brake pads suddenly lock, not a gear change. As I mentioned, it's when edging forward in a traffic jam. Typical speed probably well under 1 mph. And, as I said, I'd been told by the garage (who said they'd checked with BMW) that idling speed was correct. Also, I can find no cable adjustment. The pedal rests on some sort of roller, but the lever is out of sight and I see nothing emerging at that (very low) location inside the engine compartment. The mechanic who came out with me muttered something vague about 'all done by computer', but frankly I'm no longer confident in him. There's no way I can pull the throttle up. Trying to do so makes no difference to idle speed, and indeed I couldn't detect any movement of the pedal; seems to be prevented from moving backwards. I suspect it's just my ignorance of the terminology. I'll try quoting your reply verbatim to my garage - but sooner or later it looks as if I'd better get to a BMW dealer, which I'm beginning to regret not doing at the outset. (The local garage is literally 5 mins walk, so very hard to resist, especially when they claimed 'very familiar with servicing BMWs'!) -- Terry, West Sussex, UK |
#5
|
|||
|
|||
In article >,
Terry Pinnell > wrote: > >I gave you the likely cause last time you posted this. Why start a new > >thread? And did you have the check I suggested done? > Here's your reply from uk.rec.cars.maintenance in full, so others know > what we're on about: > --------- > "Is this the roll out change to first gear? If so, sounds like the > idle sensor is out of adjustment - on my 528 if you come to a halt > with your foor still on the throttle even slightly - by left foot > braking - you'll get a thump into first. > Try pulling the throttle *up* with your foot and see if this makes a > difference. It might just be cable adjustment - if indeed it has a > cable." > --------- > I wasn't sure I understood some of your points. For a start, what is a > 'roll out change to first gear'? It's the gearbox changing down as you roll to a halt. > The behaviour I described is a short > 'grab', as if brake pads suddenly lock, not a gear change. But that's exactly what it feels like. It 'thumps' into first gear. > As I mentioned, it's when edging forward in a traffic jam. Now hang on - edging forward, or slowing down? > Typical speed probably well under 1 mph. And, as I said, I'd been told > by the garage (who said they'd checked with BMW) that idling speed was > correct. It's not exactly to do with that. > Also, I can find no cable adjustment. The pedal rests on some sort of > roller, but the lever is out of sight and I see nothing emerging at > that (very low) location inside the engine compartment. The mechanic > who came out with me muttered something vague about 'all done by > computer', but frankly I'm no longer confident in him. The gearbox is told in some way when the engine is at idle. And it's not by the actual speed, as this of course varies slightly - cold or AC on. > There's no way I can pull the throttle up. Trying to do so makes no > difference to idle speed, and indeed I couldn't detect any movement of > the pedal; seems to be prevented from moving backwards. It was just a thought - but I'm not sure where the sensor that tells the gearbox the throttle is closed is - quite likely part of the TPS etc. > I suspect it's just my ignorance of the terminology. I'll try quoting > your reply verbatim to my garage - but sooner or later it looks as if > I'd better get to a BMW dealer, which I'm beginning to regret not > doing at the outset. (The local garage is literally 5 mins walk, so > very hard to resist, especially when they claimed 'very familiar with > servicing BMWs'!) You might do better with an auto specialist. But make sure you go out in the car with a mechanic and demonstrate the fault. All I'm saying is your symptoms are *exactly* the same as I get on my ZF auto if you left foot brake and keep a whiff of throttle on. It thumps *badly* as it comes to rest and changes to first. Thinks. Is it a Steptronic? Or can you select a second gear start? This would soon show if my theory is correct. -- *If you can read this, thank a teecher Dave Plowman London SW To e-mail, change noise into sound. |
#6
|
|||
|
|||
"Dave Plowman (News)" > wrote:
>In article >, > Terry Pinnell > wrote: >> >I gave you the likely cause last time you posted this. Why start a new >> >thread? And did you have the check I suggested done? > > >> Here's your reply from uk.rec.cars.maintenance in full, so others know >> what we're on about: >> --------- >> "Is this the roll out change to first gear? If so, sounds like the >> idle sensor is out of adjustment - on my 528 if you come to a halt >> with your foor still on the throttle even slightly - by left foot >> braking - you'll get a thump into first. > >> Try pulling the throttle *up* with your foot and see if this makes a >> difference. It might just be cable adjustment - if indeed it has a >> cable." >> --------- > >> I wasn't sure I understood some of your points. For a start, what is a >> 'roll out change to first gear'? > >It's the gearbox changing down as you roll to a halt. OK, understood now thanks. >> The behaviour I described is a short >> 'grab', as if brake pads suddenly lock, not a gear change. > >But that's exactly what it feels like. It 'thumps' into first gear. > >> As I mentioned, it's when edging forward in a traffic jam. > >Now hang on - edging forward, or slowing down? Well, both! The 'grab' obviously happens after 'accelerating' to about 1-5 mph from the nth stop during a couple of miles worth of M25 traffic jam, and braking seconds later to the (n+1)th stop. >> Typical speed probably well under 1 mph. And, as I said, I'd been told >> by the garage (who said they'd checked with BMW) that idling speed was >> correct. > >It's not exactly to do with that. > >> Also, I can find no cable adjustment. The pedal rests on some sort of >> roller, but the lever is out of sight and I see nothing emerging at >> that (very low) location inside the engine compartment. The mechanic >> who came out with me muttered something vague about 'all done by >> computer', but frankly I'm no longer confident in him. > >The gearbox is told in some way when the engine is at idle. And it's not >by the actual speed, as this of course varies slightly - cold or AC on. >> There's no way I can pull the throttle up. Trying to do so makes no >> difference to idle speed, and indeed I couldn't detect any movement of >> the pedal; seems to be prevented from moving backwards. > >It was just a thought - but I'm not sure where the sensor that tells the >gearbox the throttle is closed is - quite likely part of the TPS etc. TPS? Transmission Programming System? >> I suspect it's just my ignorance of the terminology. I'll try quoting >> your reply verbatim to my garage - but sooner or later it looks as if >> I'd better get to a BMW dealer, which I'm beginning to regret not >> doing at the outset. (The local garage is literally 5 mins walk, so >> very hard to resist, especially when they claimed 'very familiar with >> servicing BMWs'!) > >You might do better with an auto specialist. > >But make sure you go out in the car with a mechanic and demonstrate the >fault. > >All I'm saying is your symptoms are *exactly* the same as I get on my ZF >auto if you left foot brake and keep a whiff of throttle on. It thumps >*badly* as it comes to rest and changes to first. The failure of the mechanic to mention any of this clearly means he's not truly qualified on the BMW finer points. When I took it back they 'cleaned the carbs and jets' (I think those were his words), and 'checked the idle speed, and couldn't find anything wrong.' As I mentioned, he didn't argue that something was amiss when he accompanied me shortly after for a run. His stated intention (Monday) was to speak to Vines. However, he was apparently off ill for a day, so I'll give it till Monday before chasing again. Don't really want to let the local garage off the hook, as that cost me £258. >Thinks. Is it a Steptronic? Or can you select a second gear start? This >would soon show if my theory is correct. Pretty sure I can start in 2nd. I'll check and report back. When I tried it this morning (to check your 'pedal up' suggestion) one thing I did establish was that I could virtually eliminate that final 'grab' by quickly easing off the brake at the very last moment. So maybe I'm making heavy weather of this? Or maybe it really is nothing to do with idling, and somehow a brakes or brake pad issue? But then, what has changed? This routine 'Inspection Service' didn't touch the brakes. One other possibility is that maybe I've had a small split in that 'air hose' for years, and that somehow reduced the idling speed. Only after its complete failure and replacement id my idling speed now 'correct', necessitating a new driving style? -- Terry, West Sussex, UK |
#7
|
|||
|
|||
In article >,
Terry Pinnell > wrote: > >> I wasn't sure I understood some of your points. For a start, what is a > >> 'roll out change to first gear'? > > > >It's the gearbox changing down as you roll to a halt. > OK, understood now thanks. > >> The behaviour I described is a short > >> 'grab', as if brake pads suddenly lock, not a gear change. > > > >But that's exactly what it feels like. It 'thumps' into first gear. > > > >> As I mentioned, it's when edging forward in a traffic jam. > > > >Now hang on - edging forward, or slowing down? > Well, both! The 'grab' obviously happens after 'accelerating' to about > 1-5 mph from the nth stop during a couple of miles worth of M25 > traffic jam, and braking seconds later to the (n+1)th stop. But it only happens when slowing, not speeding up? Obviously you can't slow without speeding up first, but I'm interested in when the grab actually occurs. > >> Typical speed probably well under 1 mph. And, as I said, I'd been told > >> by the garage (who said they'd checked with BMW) that idling speed was > >> correct. > > > >It's not exactly to do with that. > > > >> Also, I can find no cable adjustment. The pedal rests on some sort of > >> roller, but the lever is out of sight and I see nothing emerging at > >> that (very low) location inside the engine compartment. The mechanic > >> who came out with me muttered something vague about 'all done by > >> computer', but frankly I'm no longer confident in him. > > > >The gearbox is told in some way when the engine is at idle. And it's not > >by the actual speed, as this of course varies slightly - cold or AC on. > >> There's no way I can pull the throttle up. Trying to do so makes no > >> difference to idle speed, and indeed I couldn't detect any movement of > >> the pedal; seems to be prevented from moving backwards. > > > >It was just a thought - but I'm not sure where the sensor that tells the > >gearbox the throttle is closed is - quite likely part of the TPS etc. > TPS? Transmission Programming System? Sorry - throttle position sensor. > >> I suspect it's just my ignorance of the terminology. I'll try quoting > >> your reply verbatim to my garage - but sooner or later it looks as if > >> I'd better get to a BMW dealer, which I'm beginning to regret not > >> doing at the outset. (The local garage is literally 5 mins walk, so > >> very hard to resist, especially when they claimed 'very familiar with > >> servicing BMWs'!) > > > >You might do better with an auto specialist. > > > >But make sure you go out in the car with a mechanic and demonstrate the > >fault. > > > >All I'm saying is your symptoms are *exactly* the same as I get on my ZF > >auto if you left foot brake and keep a whiff of throttle on. It thumps > >*badly* as it comes to rest and changes to first. > The failure of the mechanic to mention any of this clearly means he's > not truly qualified on the BMW finer points. When I took it back they > 'cleaned the carbs and jets' (I think those were his words), I hope not as it has neither. It has fuel injection. > and 'checked the idle speed, and couldn't find anything wrong.' As I > mentioned, he didn't argue that something was amiss when he accompanied > me shortly after for a run. His stated intention (Monday) was to speak > to Vines. However, he was apparently off ill for a day, so I'll give it > till Monday before chasing again. Don't really want to let the local > garage off the hook, as that cost me £258. Yes. It's always annoying when a fault isn't fixed. > >Thinks. Is it a Steptronic? Or can you select a second gear start? This > >would soon show if my theory is correct. > Pretty sure I can start in 2nd. I'll check and report back. > When I tried it this morning (to check your 'pedal up' suggestion) one > thing I did establish was that I could virtually eliminate that final > 'grab' by quickly easing off the brake at the very last moment. So > maybe I'm making heavy weather of this? Or maybe it really is nothing > to do with idling, and somehow a brakes or brake pad issue? But then, > what has changed? This routine 'Inspection Service' didn't touch the > brakes. Well, the symptom I'm describing on my car requires both the brake and accelerator to be depressed at once - and the accelerator only by a tiny amount. Release either and the thump doesn't happen. > One other possibility is that maybe I've had a small split in that > 'air hose' for years, and that somehow reduced the idling speed. Only > after its complete failure and replacement id my idling speed now > 'correct', necessitating a new driving style? I'd have thought you'd have seen an alteration of the idle speed on the rev counter? -- *The average person falls asleep in seven minutes * Dave Plowman London SW To e-mail, change noise into sound. |
#8
|
|||
|
|||
Terry Pinnell > wrote:
>"Dave Plowman (News)" > wrote: > >>In article >, >> Terry Pinnell > wrote: >>> >I gave you the likely cause last time you posted this. Why start a new >>> >thread? And did you have the check I suggested done? >> >> >>> Here's your reply from uk.rec.cars.maintenance in full, so others know >>> what we're on about: >>> --------- >>> "Is this the roll out change to first gear? If so, sounds like the >>> idle sensor is out of adjustment - on my 528 if you come to a halt >>> with your foor still on the throttle even slightly - by left foot >>> braking - you'll get a thump into first. >> >>> Try pulling the throttle *up* with your foot and see if this makes a >>> difference. It might just be cable adjustment - if indeed it has a >>> cable." >>> --------- >> >>> I wasn't sure I understood some of your points. For a start, what is a >>> 'roll out change to first gear'? >> >>It's the gearbox changing down as you roll to a halt. > >OK, understood now thanks. > >>> The behaviour I described is a short >>> 'grab', as if brake pads suddenly lock, not a gear change. >> >>But that's exactly what it feels like. It 'thumps' into first gear. >> >>> As I mentioned, it's when edging forward in a traffic jam. >> >>Now hang on - edging forward, or slowing down? > >Well, both! The 'grab' obviously happens after 'accelerating' to about >1-5 mph from the nth stop during a couple of miles worth of M25 >traffic jam, and braking seconds later to the (n+1)th stop. > >>> Typical speed probably well under 1 mph. And, as I said, I'd been told >>> by the garage (who said they'd checked with BMW) that idling speed was >>> correct. >> >>It's not exactly to do with that. >> >>> Also, I can find no cable adjustment. The pedal rests on some sort of >>> roller, but the lever is out of sight and I see nothing emerging at >>> that (very low) location inside the engine compartment. The mechanic >>> who came out with me muttered something vague about 'all done by >>> computer', but frankly I'm no longer confident in him. >> >>The gearbox is told in some way when the engine is at idle. And it's not >>by the actual speed, as this of course varies slightly - cold or AC on. > >>> There's no way I can pull the throttle up. Trying to do so makes no >>> difference to idle speed, and indeed I couldn't detect any movement of >>> the pedal; seems to be prevented from moving backwards. >> >>It was just a thought - but I'm not sure where the sensor that tells the >>gearbox the throttle is closed is - quite likely part of the TPS etc. > >TPS? Transmission Programming System? > >>> I suspect it's just my ignorance of the terminology. I'll try quoting >>> your reply verbatim to my garage - but sooner or later it looks as if >>> I'd better get to a BMW dealer, which I'm beginning to regret not >>> doing at the outset. (The local garage is literally 5 mins walk, so >>> very hard to resist, especially when they claimed 'very familiar with >>> servicing BMWs'!) >> >>You might do better with an auto specialist. >> >>But make sure you go out in the car with a mechanic and demonstrate the >>fault. >> >>All I'm saying is your symptoms are *exactly* the same as I get on my ZF >>auto if you left foot brake and keep a whiff of throttle on. It thumps >>*badly* as it comes to rest and changes to first. > >The failure of the mechanic to mention any of this clearly means he's >not truly qualified on the BMW finer points. When I took it back they >'cleaned the carbs and jets' (I think those were his words), and >'checked the idle speed, and couldn't find anything wrong.' As I >mentioned, he didn't argue that something was amiss when he >accompanied me shortly after for a run. His stated intention (Monday) >was to speak to Vines. However, he was apparently off ill for a day, >so I'll give it till Monday before chasing again. Don't really want to >let the local garage off the hook, as that cost me £258. > >>Thinks. Is it a Steptronic? Or can you select a second gear start? This >>would soon show if my theory is correct. > >Pretty sure I can start in 2nd. I'll check and report back. > >When I tried it this morning (to check your 'pedal up' suggestion) one >thing I did establish was that I could virtually eliminate that final >'grab' by quickly easing off the brake at the very last moment. So >maybe I'm making heavy weather of this? Or maybe it really is nothing >to do with idling, and somehow a brakes or brake pad issue? But then, >what has changed? This routine 'Inspection Service' didn't touch the >brakes. > >One other possibility is that maybe I've had a small split in that >'air hose' for years, and that somehow reduced the idling speed. Only >after its complete failure and replacement id my idling speed now >'correct', necessitating a new driving style? FWIW, it starts OK in second. I had another conversation with the local mechanic this morning. The gist was that the air hose split could have caused the computer to change its settings. My obvious question was "So, after you replaced the air hose, why didn't the computer change the settings again to match the new fuel/air proportions?" He said something about the computer possibly being faulty, but I didn't really follow. Make any sense? -- Terry, West Sussex, UK |
#9
|
|||
|
|||
In article >,
Terry Pinnell > wrote: > FWIW, it starts OK in second. And does this stop the snatching as you slow to a rest? Just that if it does, this means it *is* the box changing to first causing the problem. > I had another conversation with the local mechanic this morning. The > gist was that the air hose split could have caused the computer to > change its settings. My obvious question was "So, after you replaced > the air hose, why didn't the computer change the settings again to > match the new fuel/air proportions?" He said something about the > computer possibly being faulty, but I didn't really follow. Make any > sense? Computers get blamed for everything? In practice, the vast majority of faults put down to the engine ECU turn out to be something else like a sensor etc. In your case I'd be looking at the idle control mechanism to make sure it's clean and functioning correctly. I remember reading a report from a company which supplies re-con ECUs that over half those returned on exchange had no fault found. -- *There are 3 kinds of people: those who can count & those who can't. Dave Plowman London SW To e-mail, change noise into sound. |
#10
|
|||
|
|||
"Dave Plowman (News)" > wrote:
>In article >, > Terry Pinnell > wrote: >> FWIW, it starts OK in second. > >And does this stop the snatching as you slow to a rest? Just that if it >does, this means it *is* the box changing to first causing the problem. > >> I had another conversation with the local mechanic this morning. The >> gist was that the air hose split could have caused the computer to >> change its settings. My obvious question was "So, after you replaced >> the air hose, why didn't the computer change the settings again to >> match the new fuel/air proportions?" He said something about the >> computer possibly being faulty, but I didn't really follow. Make any >> sense? > >Computers get blamed for everything? > >In practice, the vast majority of faults put down to the engine ECU turn >out to be something else like a sensor etc. In your case I'd be looking at >the idle control mechanism to make sure it's clean and functioning >correctly. > >I remember reading a report from a company which supplies re-con ECUs that >over half those returned on exchange had no fault found. Took it to Vines this morning. Paraphrasing verdict: - not much if anything wrong - idling speed is OK, but probably was lower before, due to gradual effect of split air hose (until it failed completely), so you're seeing a difference that's hard for others to see - the control unit (ECU?) may well adapt over next 1,000 miles or so to new conditions One factor that muddies the water a bit is that idle speed does appear to change. Does it get slower when hot? And when it is running at say 600 instead of the 'correct' 750, the 'grab' is much reduced. I tried with '2' selected, and I'd convinced myself that did not grab - but mechanic claimed to detect no difference. He pointed out that at the speed we were doing (1 mph in garage forecourt), it would remain in 1st gear anyway, whether I selected D or 2. My conclusions: --------------- - At the idle speed of 700/800 I was seeing throughout a 280 mile journey over 2 days, half of it in traffic jams, prompting my posts, there was a distinct grab on the final few inches of braking; it had not been present before. - At 600, which is what I was seeing this morning, the grab is much less. I'm hoping that future idle speed (hot) remains at this level. - Perhaps the ECU is *already* beginning to 'adapt' to revised fuel/air proportions? Thanks for your patient help. -- Terry, West Sussex, UK |
Thread Tools | |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
LIDAR Trial this Week | [email protected] | Driving | 17 | April 9th 06 02:44 AM |
IN senate backs bill to raise speed limit to 70 mph | 223rem | Driving | 56 | February 22nd 05 04:21 PM |
R*volume*raduis2 c3po "Theroy of everything" | zetasum | Chrysler | 0 | February 18th 05 09:16 PM |
Where to get Official Speed Limit Info | [email protected] | Driving | 40 | January 3rd 05 07:10 AM |
Co must be full of 'em | Brent P | Driving | 58 | December 26th 04 10:45 PM |