If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the FAQ by clicking the link above. You may have to register before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below. |
|
|
Thread Tools | Display Modes |
#1
|
|||
|
|||
Rebuildable Rabbit Front Strut Bearings
I've just acquired a pair of the old-style A1 strut bearings (the kind
that came on the 75 and 76 rabbits, I believe). I'm getting ready to redo the suspension on my 84 rabbit. But I've just been told that early rabbit springs were slightly different that later rabbit springs. Specifically, I heard that the later rabbit springs were smaller at the ends. The person I was talking to said that if I was intending to use the older style strut bearings on my '84 rabbit, then when I purchased replacement oem springs, I needed to be sure that I ordered oem springs for one of these early rabbits. OEM springs for an '84 rabbit won't work on the earlier bearings, he said. Can somebody please confirm/deny this? Thanks, Bryan -- remove the "REMOVE" from my email to email |
Ads |
#2
|
|||
|
|||
Rebuildable Rabbit Front Strut Bearings
Bryan K. Walton wrote:
> I've just acquired a pair of the old-style A1 strut bearings (the kind > that came on the 75 and 76 rabbits, I believe). I'm getting ready to > redo the suspension on my 84 rabbit. But I've just been told > that early rabbit springs were slightly different that later rabbit > springs. Specifically, I heard that the later rabbit springs were > smaller at the ends. The person I was talking to said that if I was > intending to use the older style strut bearings on my '84 rabbit, then > when I purchased replacement oem springs, I needed to be sure that I > ordered oem springs for one of these early rabbits. OEM springs for an > '84 rabbit won't work on the earlier bearings, he said. Can somebody > please confirm/deny this? > > Thanks, > Bryan > I didn't think it made a difference so long as you used the right upper spring seat. But I've been known to be wrong before. nate -- replace "fly" with "com" to reply. http://home.comcast.net/~njnagel |
#3
|
|||
|
|||
Rebuildable Rabbit Front Strut Bearings
Early Rabbit and Scirocco 74-79 had front springs with all equal sized
coils. The 80 on models came with springs that had a smaller diameter coil, or pig tail at the top. All the coils were the same diameter except the top coil which is smaller. The newer style springs last longer , have less breakage due to fatigue. There is a plate between the spring and the upper bearing, called the upper spring mount. If you use the older spring, you must use the older spring mount to seat the spring. If you use the newer spring, then you get a new upper spring mount to match the new spring. The strut bearing is the same from75-88. rabbit Scirocco. Your strut bearings are not different and will work, on either spring style. Also Rabbits ,Sciroccos, Jettas 75-84 have external threads on the strut casing. Internal threads are used on USA Rabbits 79-83. But many have been converted. If you do change the struts. You must get the ones for internal, or external threads, which ever you have. Remember to put gear lube or engine oil in the casing, so the strut will be removable next time and not rusted in. I use old engine or gear lube for this. Make sure it squeezes out when you insert the new strut so it fills the whole space. I once disassembled the front struts on a 80 rabbit in a buddies garage and could not get it back together because I bought the older springs which fell right around the newer upper spring mounts that were on the car. I could not find the older spring mount anywhere and had to buy the newer style spring to match my spring mounts. "Bryan K. Walton" > wrote in message ink.com... > I've just acquired a pair of the old-style A1 strut bearings (the kind > that came on the 75 and 76 rabbits, I believe). I'm getting ready to > redo the suspension on my 84 rabbit. But I've just been told > that early rabbit springs were slightly different that later rabbit > springs. Specifically, I heard that the later rabbit springs were > smaller at the ends. The person I was talking to said that if I was > intending to use the older style strut bearings on my '84 rabbit, then > when I purchased replacement oem springs, I needed to be sure that I > ordered oem springs for one of these early rabbits. OEM springs for an > '84 rabbit won't work on the earlier bearings, he said. Can somebody > please confirm/deny this? > > Thanks, > Bryan > > -- > remove the "REMOVE" from my email to email |
#4
|
|||
|
|||
Rebuildable Rabbit Front Strut Bearings
On 2006-04-03, none2u > wrote:
> breakage due to fatigue. There is a plate between the spring and the upper > bearing, called the upper spring mount. If you use the older spring, you > must use the older spring mount to seat the spring. If you use the newer > spring, then you get a new upper spring mount to match the new spring. The OK. This makes sense. If I'm using the newer spring (and the spring I'm replacing is also the newer spring) can I reuse the upper spring mount from that which I'm replacing? More simply put, do I need to use brand new upper spring mounts every time I replace springs/struts? > are not different and will work, on either spring style. Also Rabbits > ,Sciroccos, Jettas 75-84 have external threads on the strut casing. Internal > threads are used on USA Rabbits 79-83. But many have been converted. If you I'm a little confused here. So a USA '84 would be EXTERNAL? > do change the struts. You must get the ones for internal, or external > threads, which ever you have. Remember to put gear lube or engine oil in the > casing, so the strut will be removable next time and not rusted in. I use > old engine or gear lube for this. Make sure it squeezes out when you insert > the new strut so it fills the whole space. I once disassembled the front Thanks for this tip. I think I'm probably going to buy new housings, mine are rusted pretty thoroughly. I can't be sure, as I don't know the full history of this rabbit, but my hunch is that the struts/springs, have never been replaced. They are in bad shape. Thank you everybody for your help! Bryan -- remove the "REMOVE" from my email to email |
#5
|
|||
|
|||
Rebuildable Rabbit Front Strut Bearings
Bryan K. Walton wrote: > On 2006-04-03, none2u > wrote: > > breakage due to fatigue. There is a plate between the spring and the upper > > bearing, called the upper spring mount. If you use the older spring, you > > must use the older spring mount to seat the spring. If you use the newer > > spring, then you get a new upper spring mount to match the new spring. The > > OK. This makes sense. If I'm using the newer spring (and the spring > I'm replacing is also the newer spring) can I reuse the upper spring > mount from that which I'm replacing? That's my understanding, yes, but I can't give you a 100% on that. > More simply put, do I need to > use brand new upper spring mounts every time I replace springs/struts? > No, I think you just need to use the ones appropriate to the springs that you are using. > > are not different and will work, on either spring style. Also Rabbits > > ,Sciroccos, Jettas 75-84 have external threads on the strut casing. Internal > > threads are used on USA Rabbits 79-83. But many have been converted. If you > > I'm a little confused here. So a USA '84 would be EXTERNAL? > I believe so, that seems to be my recollection from doing the front end on my '84 Wabbit GTI. Doesn't make any difference to the spring seat or strut bearing though, only what kind of struts you need to order. Boge sucks BTW. > > do change the struts. You must get the ones for internal, or external > > threads, which ever you have. Remember to put gear lube or engine oil in the > > casing, so the strut will be removable next time and not rusted in. I use > > old engine or gear lube for this. Make sure it squeezes out when you insert > > the new strut so it fills the whole space. I once disassembled the front > > Thanks for this tip. I think I'm probably going to buy new housings, > mine are rusted pretty thoroughly. I can't be sure, as I don't know > the full history of this rabbit, but my hunch is that the > struts/springs, have never been replaced. They are in bad shape. Good luck with the replacement then, I had to cut the caps off the struts on my GTI; there was no way to non-destructively remove them. Fortunately the replacement struts came with new caps (I think this was the Boge set) but I had to replace them with Konis in only a couple years because they wore out amazingly fast. nate |
#6
|
|||
|
|||
Rebuildable Rabbit Front Strut Bearings
On 2006-04-04, N8N > wrote:
> > Bryan K. Walton wrote: >> OK. This makes sense. If I'm using the newer spring (and the spring >> I'm replacing is also the newer spring) can I reuse the upper spring >> mount from that which I'm replacing? > > That's my understanding, yes, but I can't give you a 100% on that. OK. >> More simply put, do I need to >> use brand new upper spring mounts every time I replace springs/struts? > > No, I think you just need to use the ones appropriate to the springs > that you are using. OK. >> I'm a little confused here. So a USA '84 would be EXTERNAL? > > I believe so, that seems to be my recollection from doing the front end > on my '84 Wabbit GTI. Doesn't make any difference to the spring seat > or strut bearing though, only what kind of struts you need to order. > Boge sucks BTW. Thanks. -- remove the "REMOVE" from my email to email |
#7
|
|||
|
|||
Rebuildable Rabbit Front Strut Bearings
You do not need to use brand new upper spring mounts every time you replace
the struts. Its nothing more then a piece of steel molded to the spring, with a hole in it for the strut to go through. You reuse it all the time until it rots , or you get the other springs, then you need the other one. Put some paint on it if you want. There's external and internal threads for the strut nut. The 84 should be external threads. Its easy to look at your car and see which you have. I gave the years but it doesn't matter because people use what they buy, and you just know,what's on your car unless you look. If you're buying new strut housings , It doesn't matter anyway. You can see what's on the new ones and order the appropriate struts, with the correct nuts. Summary. Your bearings will work. Springs have matching upper spring mounts. Strut housings have internal or external threads. The new struts have a matching internal or external nut for the housing. And the kicker,, there's rubber snubbers, or bumper stops, and a plastic cap that go on the strut to keep them from bottoming out, and keep dirt off the chrome part. Good luck... Since you seem to be willing to buy so many parts .. I will add the following because this may be cheaper or easier or both. Parts place for VWs has brand new completely assembled front strut assemblies , housings, springs, struts bearings, mounts ,snubbers, caps . Completely done for, 259 front pair. This means you remove two bottom bolts and two top bolts and they are out. The Springs are already mounted. They are Sachs or Boge. OEM. with firmer US springs. They have a core charge of 18 bucks but have a rebate for $20 off. I suspect all your parts ,because you're buying housings will be more then that. But your way means you have to mount the springs. There phone number is 1-248-373-2300 . the struts number is sn 13691 The rebate number is 16386. The core needs to be there in 30 days or you lose your 18 bucks. They sell a rebuild kit for 159 too, without the housing , but it has everything else brand new with old style springs. So you have to find the upper mounts old style. Its Boge too. external No.1996, internal No. 3947. No rebate or core. I don't work there , just trying to help.. "Bryan K. Walton" > wrote in message ink.com... > On 2006-04-04, N8N > wrote: >> >> Bryan K. Walton wrote: >>> OK. This makes sense. If I'm using the newer spring (and the spring >>> I'm replacing is also the newer spring) can I reuse the upper spring >>> mount from that which I'm replacing? >> >> That's my understanding, yes, but I can't give you a 100% on that. > > OK. > >>> More simply put, do I need to >>> use brand new upper spring mounts every time I replace springs/struts? >> >> No, I think you just need to use the ones appropriate to the springs >> that you are using. > > OK. > >>> I'm a little confused here. So a USA '84 would be EXTERNAL? >> >> I believe so, that seems to be my recollection from doing the front end >> on my '84 Wabbit GTI. Doesn't make any difference to the spring seat >> or strut bearing though, only what kind of struts you need to order. >> Boge sucks BTW. > > Thanks. > > > -- > remove the "REMOVE" from my email to email |
#8
|
|||
|
|||
Rebuildable Rabbit Front Strut Bearings
Everything bryan wrote here is absolutely correct. Good luck.
"Bryan K. Walton" > wrote in message ink.com... > On 2006-04-04, N8N > wrote: >> >> Bryan K. Walton wrote: >>> OK. This makes sense. If I'm using the newer spring (and the spring >>> I'm replacing is also the newer spring) can I reuse the upper spring >>> mount from that which I'm replacing? >> >> That's my understanding, yes, but I can't give you a 100% on that. > > OK. > >>> More simply put, do I need to >>> use brand new upper spring mounts every time I replace springs/struts? >> >> No, I think you just need to use the ones appropriate to the springs >> that you are using. > > OK. > >>> I'm a little confused here. So a USA '84 would be EXTERNAL? >> >> I believe so, that seems to be my recollection from doing the front end >> on my '84 Wabbit GTI. Doesn't make any difference to the spring seat >> or strut bearing though, only what kind of struts you need to order. >> Boge sucks BTW. > > Thanks. > > > -- > remove the "REMOVE" from my email to email |
#9
|
|||
|
|||
Rebuildable Rabbit Front Strut Bearings
On 2006-04-04, none2u > wrote:
> Put some paint on it if you want. There's external and internal threads for > the strut nut. The 84 should be external threads. Its easy to look at your > car and see which you have. I gave the years but it doesn't matter because > people use what they buy, and you just know,what's on your car unless you > look. If you're buying new strut housings , It doesn't matter anyway. You Thanks again for the helpful reply. One final question for you and others, assuming I can get struts for both internally and externally threaded strut housings, what are peoples thoughts on the two options with regard to the housings? Assuming that I have access to both, is one type of thread considered better (easier to work with, or one that ages better -- with regard to rust)? Thanks! Bryan -- remove the "REMOVE" from my email to email |
#10
|
|||
|
|||
Rebuildable Rabbit Front Strut Bearings
I don't know about that. It may be just that the US ones were made here, so
they were different. I,d accept whatever the parts store had . but I think I'd want the easiest ones to get the nut off, ,which seems to be the external ones. I would want the later pigtail springs because they lasted longer. But I,d take the ones that match the upper mounts. Because I never found any anywhere except a junk yard. If you're worried about rust and getting them apart again in 5 years, Then I,d put antiseize compound on the nut threads too. Also don't forget your plastic caps and the snubbers. The plastic caps are there to keep the dirt off your chrome piston and keep it from getting inside the strut and damaging the seal when your strut moves up and down. The snubbers keep your suspension from bottoming out and breaking something. If you leave these off you will need struts long before the rust gets to them .I wouldn't be surprised if people who say their struts were crap, left these off. Logically you could say that the internal threads should last longer as they aren't exposed to salt spray. But they rot just as fast inside as out unless you fill them with old engine oil or gear lube. And the external nuts seem easier to get out if it has to be destructed. "Bryan K. Walton" > wrote in message ink.com... > On 2006-04-04, none2u > wrote: >> Put some paint on it if you want. There's external and internal threads >> for >> the strut nut. The 84 should be external threads. Its easy to look at >> your >> car and see which you have. I gave the years but it doesn't matter >> because >> people use what they buy, and you just know,what's on your car unless you >> look. If you're buying new strut housings , It doesn't matter anyway. >> You > > Thanks again for the helpful reply. One final question for you and > others, assuming I can get struts for both internally and externally > threaded strut housings, what are peoples thoughts on the two options > with regard to the housings? Assuming that I have access to both, is > one type of thread considered better (easier to work with, or one that > ages better -- with regard to rust)? > > Thanks! > Bryan > > -- > remove the "REMOVE" from my email to email |
Thread Tools | |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
71 ghia rear wheel bearings: do they 'run in oil' or are they 'packedwith grease'? | dave | VW air cooled | 4 | March 8th 06 05:38 PM |
sealed "lifetime" vs. non-sealed front wheel bearings | [email protected] | Technology | 7 | February 1st 06 05:21 PM |
75 front wheel bearings and ball joints | Catman | Alfa Romeo | 2 | October 27th 04 06:55 AM |
A4 - Front Wheel Bearings ? | Graeme | Audi | 1 | July 15th 04 12:47 PM |
88 Suzuki - Front end problem | xyzzy | 4x4 | 14 | March 13th 04 07:43 PM |