If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the FAQ by clicking the link above. You may have to register before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below. |
|
|
Thread Tools | Display Modes |
#21
|
|||
|
|||
Max wrote:
> Because the USA is so horribly conserverative they can't stand any > titties or f-words in television advertisments. Oh, yeah, "titties" and the f-word raise the level of discourse in this country immeasurably. John -- To reply, remove "die.spammers" from address Von Herzen, moge es wieder zu Herzen gehen. --Beethoven |
Ads |
#22
|
|||
|
|||
Anthony Giorgianni wrote:
> The question of automobile advertising is a very interesting one. > > I think manufacturers simply are appealing to this strange idea that fast, > powerful cars equal fast, powerful person. Yet, as I've said here before, > when someone drives a car, it is the car doing the work - creating the > horsepower. The person is sitting there on foam rubber, behind > plastic-coated safety glass, pushing their big toe down on the pedal. Even > an 85-year-old woman can cruise around at 80 mph. It's not big deal. But for > some reason that I don't understand, people transfer this sense of power to > themselves, as though it comes from themselves and proves something about > themselves. This I think is especially true with males, who want to > demonstrate their top place in the pecking order. Of course it is a > different thing with a NASCAR driver on a track, who can push his skills as > much as much as the vehicle. > > I also think that for some people it has to do with the thrill of feeling > the various forces - like a roller coaster. I think this is especially the > case for kids, who don't yet understand the dangers of pushing vehicles to > their limits on public roads. Volkswagen of course targets the younger > market. I think Volkswagen's commercials are among the worst. Again, if your memory goes back far enough, Subaru in the early 90s tried an experiment with "anti-car" commercials, done by the agency Weiden-Kennedy. They began with phrase like "A car is just a car...it's glass, rubber, plastic and steel. A machine. It won't make you younger or sexier and if it improves your standard with the neighbors you live among snobs with distorted values." Witty, counter-intuitive, it whispered when everyone else shouted, it zigged when everyone else zagged. It also bombed horribly, Subaru sales plunged even lower than they had already been, and they were yanked within a year and Weiden-Kennedy lost the account. John -- To reply, remove "die.spammers" from address Von Herzen, moge es wieder zu Herzen gehen. --Beethoven |
#23
|
|||
|
|||
Anthony Giorgianni wrote:
> We;re not talking about power in the sense of the engine's power, but power > in the sense of the car making the driver feel powerful, having the ability > to place himself ahead of the herd and to get a thrill at the same time. > This is what I object to. I do not mind a commercial that shows a car's > handling as it's used to avoid an accident for example. But some guy > giggling like a moron and jeering at someone in the right lane in a ... > minivan is it? ... is sending a bad message to some young kid who is likely > going to buy a Volkswagen. > > About a commercial that says:: > > "At Volkswagen, we provide you with the handling necessary to drive safely. > Now please, provide the rest. Drive responsibly." Cars, like alcohol, tobacco, blue jeans, and Carribean cruises, are selling fantasy, image. Ads don't say things like "Don't spend your money on this cruise if you can't afford it" or "Stick some comdoms in those tight-assed jeans, girl!" either, and the alcohol and Philip Morris ones only urge people to behave responsibly now because the government makes them say it. John -- To reply, remove "die.spammers" from address Von Herzen, moge es wieder zu Herzen gehen. --Beethoven |
#24
|
|||
|
|||
Daniel J. Stern wrote:
> Commercials outside the North American market are more often funny and > clever 'cause it's safe to assume the audience has a sense of humour and > that some idiot won't sue for hurt feelings after seeing the ad. > > DS Yes, indeed European and Australian audiences are generally more sophisticated and more receptive to irony and humor, and companies are braver and not as much in the grip of lawyers and marketers overseas. I've seen terrific ad campaigns killed because the client (the advertiser) received *one* angry letter. One! > For the same reason all the rest of the crap on TV does the same thing. > Turn the ****in' thing off, problem solved. > Seconded! John -- To reply, remove "die.spammers" from address Von Herzen, moge es wieder zu Herzen gehen. --Beethoven |
#26
|
|||
|
|||
"The Lindbergh Baby" > wrote in message ... > VW is actually a good client. Your memory may be short, but back in the > 1990s it did some absolutely terrific work, "Mr. Roboto" being one of the > funniest and smartest commercials I've ever seen. There's an old VW commercial, for the Golf, that had "Da da da" by Trio as the music. They drove around, stopped when they found a chair in the garbage, loaded it in the car, started driving again, then noticed how bad the chair smelled, and dumped it back out... trust me, it was much better than I'm describing. |
#27
|
|||
|
|||
Thanks for the response Scott. Very interesting.
As I said, I think it is true that lots of people drive fast out of a testosterone-induced sense of machismo (notice you don't have a lot of women here clamoring for the 85th percentile) some drive fast for the thrills and some drive fast to get somewhere fast. I'm not sure why you need to drive a high-performance vehicle to escape a sloth. But okay. As far as personal responsibility, we agree there. However, some people are not personally responsible and they are very impressionable, especially kids who haven't experienced the unpredictable dangers you can encounter while driving. I really don't want some inexperienced young driver deciding it's okay to test the cornering limits of his VW while he's driving next to me because a commercial gives him the idea this is permissible and a cool and fun thing to do. Similarly, I don't want drivers speeding pass me in snow with their SUVs because the commercial makes SUVs look invincible and creates the impression that it should be driven fast and wildly in snow. There's a lot to be said for the personal responsibility of the automakers, too. And if they are going to depict the SUV as invincible when it isn't, they should bear some of the responsibility when someone with bad judgment takes their commercial literally and crashes into me, despite the tiny type that says: Don't drive in the stupid way we're driving. -- Regards, Anthony Giorgianni The return address for this post is fictitious. Please reply by posting back to the newsgroup. |
#28
|
|||
|
|||
Greet reference John. I'm saving that.
I don't remember those Subaru ads, and I certainly wouldn't have known the name of the advertising agency. Safety sells much more today than it did in those days ... but perhaps better with certain makes than others. It is unfortunate if automakers cannot sell cars without appealing to that fast, powerful and exciting image. I just saw an ad for some automaker (Ford maybe), I think, depicting a motorcycle gang being afraid to stop at a diner because of all the automakers' trucks lined up outside. The announcer says: We don't only make our trucks powerful, we make you powerful...or something like that. I find that kind of advertising ludicrous and insulting, though I guess people are dumb enough to buy it. Next time I run into a Hells Angels member, I'll have to ask him how intimidated he is by Ford pickup truck owners. :O) -- Regards, Anthony Giorgianni The return address for this post is fictitious. Please reply by posting back to the newsgroup. "The Lindbergh Baby" > wrote in message ... > Anthony Giorgianni wrote: > > The question of automobile advertising is a very interesting one. > > > > I think manufacturers simply are appealing to this strange idea that fast, > > powerful cars equal fast, powerful person. Yet, as I've said here before, > > when someone drives a car, it is the car doing the work - creating the > > horsepower. The person is sitting there on foam rubber, behind > > plastic-coated safety glass, pushing their big toe down on the pedal. Even > > an 85-year-old woman can cruise around at 80 mph. It's not big deal. But for > > some reason that I don't understand, people transfer this sense of power to > > themselves, as though it comes from themselves and proves something about > > themselves. This I think is especially true with males, who want to > > demonstrate their top place in the pecking order. Of course it is a > > different thing with a NASCAR driver on a track, who can push his skills as > > much as much as the vehicle. > > |
#29
|
|||
|
|||
Jim Yanik wrote: > A car that goes fast only in a straight line is not much good. Tell that to John Force ... -- C.R. Krieger (Been there; done that) |
#30
|
|||
|
|||
Anthony Giorgianni wrote:
> Thanks for the response Scott. Very interesting. > > I'm not sure why you need to drive a high-performance vehicle to escape a > sloth. But okay. > > Similarly, I don't want drivers speeding pass me in snow with their SUVs > because the commercial makes SUVs look invincible and creates the impression > that it should be driven fast and wildly in snow. So it's OK for Scott to drive fast when it's warm and dry but not for a similar driver (like me) to do the same when it's snowy? Heck, I have always *loved* driving in snow in just about anything, and commercials have nothing to do with it. I *teach* high performance track driving, I've rallied in all-night blizzards, and I've taught ice driving on a frozen lake. Do you think I can't handle snow *in a Jeep*? As with my 3-season BMW, I'm not doing this to show off. I enjoy slinging my Grand Cherokee into a 4-wheel 4WD drift in six inches of snow as much as I enjoy slinging my 535is through Turn Six at Road America. In fact, I have more fun when there aren't any frightened 'citizens' around to see me. The only gratification I get from guys like you is knowing that you're thinking how you'll see me upside down or offroad a few miles down the road - and you never do. -- C.R. Krieger (Been there; done that - last month) |
Thread Tools | |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
Dumb Question.... | cassie | Mazda | 5 | February 5th 05 02:43 PM |
Dodge truck commercials... | N8N | Driving | 3 | January 25th 05 02:29 AM |
Fat, Dumb Trucker Makes Fun of Californians | Johnny Lately | Driving | 18 | January 6th 05 06:05 PM |
Dumb accident with '86 TQ, question about bent frame | cp | Audi | 10 | December 22nd 04 09:44 PM |
A dumb question: Smaller offset wheels vs lowering | Stu | General | 5 | April 1st 04 03:19 PM |