If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the FAQ by clicking the link above. You may have to register before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below. |
|
|
Thread Tools | Display Modes |
#1
|
|||
|
|||
94 Civic: coolant drain/flush and thermostat
I recently had a stuck thermostat at an inopportune time, and had to get
whatever CarQuest supplied the mechanic instead of OEM as I had figured to put in when I replaced the coolant later this summer. I still have to replace the coolant and bleed the system, which wasn't done during thermostat replacement. I never had a problem with OEM thermostats in American cars. Any particular reason to replace the new aftermarket with OEM here, when I change the coolant? I wouldn't mind a thermostat that stuck open when it failed instead of closed, actually, but since they don't fail all that much I suppose it isn't really worth it. Also, what's the best way to flush out the crud? There's some nasty-looking green **** in there now and I have no idea what was put in last--i.e., whether it was the right stuff for an aluminum block. On my 85 Pontiac (large engine, lots of room under the hood) I'd just use a flush kit that allowed me to hook up a garden hose to the coolant system. Would drain the old coolant, then refill, run the engine a few minutes to get things circulating, then drain again. I suppose if I wanted to get water contaminants out after that I could run distilled water through after that and drain again. Thoughts? |
Ads |
#2
|
|||
|
|||
"Abeness" > wrote
> I recently had a stuck thermostat at an inopportune time, and had to get > whatever CarQuest supplied the mechanic instead of OEM as I had figured > to put in when I replaced the coolant later this summer. I still have to > replace the coolant and bleed the system, which wasn't done during > thermostat replacement. > > I never had a problem with OEM thermostats in American cars. Any > particular reason to replace the new aftermarket with OEM here, when I > change the coolant? I wouldn't mind a thermostat that stuck open when it > failed instead of closed, actually, but since they don't fail all that > much I suppose it isn't really worth it. I paid about $18 last year for an OEM thermostat for my 1991 Civic. My recollection is folks here said the OEM was worth it. $18 seems cheap enough, compared to IIRC something like $10-$12 for non-OEM. > Also, what's the best way to flush out the crud? There's some > nasty-looking green **** in there now and I have no idea what was put in > last--i.e., whether it was the right stuff for an aluminum block. I would dump this and flush the engine block and lines immediately. From reports here and one of my own experiences, the conventional green stuff will greatly shorten your Civic's water pump's life. The good news, though, is that, if your 94 Civic is like my 91 Civic, it should be easy to give a pretty thorough flush. (It's more of a fill and drain as opposed to flush.) The reason it should be easy is that, by (1) opening the petcock on the radiator; (2) removing the engine block coolant drain bolt; and (3) emptying the reservoir, all coolant should come out of the system. I did careful measurements of what came out of (1) and (2) and they matched exactly what the manual stated should be the capacity for the system. Here are my hints on the job. The hardest part will likely be removing the engine drain bolt. But even that was very easy on my car this time. Others have some horror stories on this, though. -- Tips on Draining, Flushing, and Filling 91 Civic Radiator/Coolant System ---- Engine block drain bolt: The car's front hung out of the garage a little, so I had plenty of sunlight to see as well as possible the engine block drain bolt. The only interference I removed was the air intake duct (two bolts) and the O2 sensor wire from its bracket (just laid it aside without disconnecting anything electrically). I used a 19 mm 8-faced long socket and an 18-inch breaker bar on the drain bolt. It wasn't going to come free easily with anything with a shorter handle; I tried my ratchet. I applied force but not so much that I thought I needed to lay pillows on the car, to break my fall, in an extreme case. Thought I felt it break loose. Son of a gun, it had loosened. By my records, the last time I had it off was 12 years ago. For other folks, I suggest maybe spraying down the drain bolt head with PB Blaster and wipe before trying to loosen it. Even though it came off easily this time, it was quite gunked up and greasy, and I think this, combined with not having a 19 mm socket, was why the first time I did this it was was hellacious. I really beat up one face of that bolt some 12 years ago. Flush: Per Tegger's suggestion and experience, I removed the engine block drain bolt, closed the radiator petcock, and put a garden hose into the radiator filler neck. Run until clear. Then open the radiator petcock and drain. I did discover that the path of hose water flow is through the upper radiator hose (from top of radiator to top of engine block), somewhat through the block, and out the engine block's coolant drain bolt hole. I speculate that the thermostat housing approach is more effective. It's also more trouble, or it would have been for me this time around. About 1/8 teaspoon of sandy residue (both brown and white) came out of the engine block with the old coolant, so I'm glad I took off the drain bolt and "properly" drained the block. I used (Permatex Ultra Grey) non-hardening sealant on the drain bolt threads, per my manual's instructions. Permatex Ultra-Grey is advertised as suitable for the water pump, so it made sense to me that it would be fine for the drain bolt. During the fill part of the procedure, I had to wait 36 minutes for the fan to come on the first time; five minutes more to come on the second time. It was 64 degrees F ambient temperature here. I have been using the Orange Dexcool for the last 2.5 years in my Civic's engine. It's supposed to be good for aluminum engines. Some others here say they are using it in their Hondas, without problems. Still others say do not experiment; it's not worth the risk; just by the pre-mixed Honda coolant from your dealer. In conclusion, I now have about as perfect a mix as possible of 50% Dex and 50% distilled water this time. Environmentally speaking, I didn't have all that flushed, coolant-contaminated water to dispose of; just the roughly 1.35 gallons of old coolant. |
#3
|
|||
|
|||
Elle wrote:
> I paid about $18 last year for an OEM thermostat for my 1991 Civic. My > recollection is folks here said the OEM was worth it. $18 seems cheap > enough, compared to IIRC something like $10-$12 for non-OEM. Right--I'm not worried about the cost, just whether it might be important, now that I've got a brand-new aftermarket in there (not by my choice), to replace the brand-new aftermarket with OEM. I too have noted that some folks here prefer OEM thermostats. > The good news, though, > is that, if your 94 Civic is like my 91 Civic, it should be easy to give a > pretty thorough flush. (It's more of a fill and drain as opposed to flush.) > The reason it should be easy is that, by (1) opening the petcock on the > radiator; (2) removing the engine block coolant drain bolt; and (3) emptying > the reservoir, all coolant should come out of the system. I did careful > measurements of what came out of (1) and (2) and they matched exactly what > the manual stated should be the capacity for the system. Thanks for this info and all the tips, Elle, exactly what I was looking for. Alas, my socket sets don't include a 19 mm socket (if mine's the same size)... Phooey. Well, I'll give a combo wrench a shot. > I used (Permatex Ultra Grey) non-hardening sealant on the drain bolt > threads, per my manual's instructions. Permatex Ultra-Grey is advertised as > suitable for the water pump, so it made sense to me that it would be fine > for the drain bolt. Is this the stuff (one option, anyway) that's meant by "liquid gasket"? I assume that using it would obviate the need for a washer. > I have been using the Orange Dexcool for the last 2.5 years in my Civic's > engine. It's supposed to be good for aluminum engines. Some others here say > they are using it in their Hondas, without problems. Still others say do not > experiment; it's not worth the risk; just by the pre-mixed Honda coolant > from your dealer. That's what I'll probably do, as I need to head down to the dealer to pick up some manual tranny oil anyway, and don't want lots of extra coolant lying around--no space. I had planned to use ordinary 10w-30 as specified by the service manual till others here suggested that the chemicals might not be right. Wonder what Honda uses... maybe ordinary 10w-30! ;-) > Environmentally speaking, I didn't have all > that flushed, coolant-contaminated water to dispose of; just the roughly > 1.35 gallons of old coolant. Yup, I'll probably do the same. Hopefully the local parts place will take the old coolant. I've got a bunch of old brake fluid to dispose of as well. Amazingly, my 1.6L engine holds only 1 gallon (plus the reservoir, I presume). IIRC my old Pontiac held around 4! |
#4
|
|||
|
|||
"Abeness" > wrote
> Elle wrote: > > I paid about $18 last year for an OEM thermostat for my 1991 Civic. My > > recollection is folks here said the OEM was worth it. $18 seems cheap > > enough, compared to IIRC something like $10-$12 for non-OEM. > > Right--I'm not worried about the cost, just whether it might be > important, now that I've got a brand-new aftermarket in there (not by my > choice), to replace the brand-new aftermarket with OEM. I too have noted > that some folks here prefer OEM thermostats. Just a thought: Maybe the thing won't fail catastrophically any sooner than the OEM, but it might not regulate temperatures optimally. I think the biggest concern is different temperature setpoints for opening and closing the thermostat valve. So other engine components, particularly those that regulate engine operation, may not operate optimally. I'm sure some of the regulars here can add to this. > > The good news, though, > > is that, if your 94 Civic is like my 91 Civic, it should be easy to give a > > pretty thorough flush. (It's more of a fill and drain as opposed to flush.) > > The reason it should be easy is that, by (1) opening the petcock on the > > radiator; (2) removing the engine block coolant drain bolt; and (3) emptying > > the reservoir, all coolant should come out of the system. I did careful > > measurements of what came out of (1) and (2) and they matched exactly what > > the manual stated should be the capacity for the system. > > Thanks for this info and all the tips, Elle, exactly what I was looking > for. Alas, my socket sets don't include a 19 mm socket (if mine's the > same size)... Phooey. Well, I'll give a combo wrench a shot. Have another car standing by so you can run to Autozone and buy a 19 mm socket (six-faced, not eight-faced, doh, pardon my earlier post-o) as needed. :-) Autozone IIRC will probably have the socket for under $6. I am pleased with the sockets I've bought in the past from Autozone and found Autozone cheaper than Pep Boys and Sears for sockets. Of course, one may get what one pays for. > > I used (Permatex Ultra Grey) non-hardening sealant on the drain bolt > > threads, per my manual's instructions. Permatex Ultra-Grey is advertised as > > suitable for the water pump, so it made sense to me that it would be fine > > for the drain bolt. > > Is this the stuff (one option, anyway) that's meant by "liquid gasket"? Yes. For example, the Permatex Ultra Grey's label includes the words "sensor safe RTV silicone gasket maker." But there are a few different grades of the stuff. The permatex.com site has a good description of the different grades. Or just go to Autozone and read what's on the packaging of the three or so grades it will likely have. > I assume that using it would obviate the need for a washer. I just checked Majestic's online parts site to compare a 94 Civic LX's drain bolt with my 91 Civic LX's. It appears under "Cylinder Block-Oil Pan." The 91's and the 94's are the same. They use a 28 mm washer. I've never replaced it and probably should. My Civic Owner's Manual directs that "non-hardening sealant" be applied to the drain bolt threads. (Chilton's says nothing about this. But I trust the Owner's manual more for this.) > > I have been using the Orange Dexcool for the last 2.5 years in my Civic's > > engine. It's supposed to be good for aluminum engines. Some others here say > > they are using it in their Hondas, without problems. Still others say do not > > experiment; it's not worth the risk; just by the pre-mixed Honda coolant > > from your dealer. > > That's what I'll probably do, as I need to head down to the dealer to > pick up some manual tranny oil anyway, and don't want lots of extra > coolant lying around--no space. True; you will only use about half of the gallon of DexCool. > I had planned to use ordinary 10w-30 as > specified by the service manual till others here suggested that the > chemicals might not be right. Wonder what Honda uses... maybe ordinary > 10w-30! ;-) Well, I have been quite happy with Pennzoil 5W-30 for my car's engine oil, for all its life. I mean, I notice nothing bad happening from it, at 168k miles and 14 years. (5W-30 is the weight my owner's manual recommends for my climate.) > > Environmentally speaking, I didn't have all > > that flushed, coolant-contaminated water to dispose of; just the roughly > > 1.35 gallons of old coolant. > > Yup, I'll probably do the same. Hopefully the local parts place will > take the old coolant. I've got a bunch of old brake fluid to dispose of > as well. For stuff like this, I've had a lot of luck with either (1) local government run recycling centers; or (2) hazardous material recycling drives a couple times a year; and (3) places like Autozone and independent garages taking the stuff off my hands. Maybe check your yellow pages for "recycling." Or call your city hall. They've always been eager to help with matters like this. Some folks say where they live, the law allows them to dump anti-freeze down the drain sewer. > Amazingly, my 1.6L engine holds only 1 gallon (plus the > reservoir, I presume). This is similar to the capacity of my 1.5 Liter engine. Your owner's manual, if you have one, has the exact specs. Or there are some sites online that will have it, like the free repair guides at www.autozone.com . > IIRC my old Pontiac held around 4! Honda rocks. |
#5
|
|||
|
|||
Elle wrote:
> Just a thought: Maybe the thing won't fail catastrophically any sooner than > the OEM, but it might not regulate temperatures optimally. That wouldn't kill me. I suspect it's close enough. > Have another car standing by so you can run to Autozone and buy a 19 mm > socket (six-faced, not eight-faced, doh, pardon my earlier post-o) as > needed. :-) Oh, no need for that, there's an autoparts place (Strauss) just a few blocks away, and anyway I'd try to loosen the plug first--the coolant doesn't pour out just from cracking it loose, if I got lucky. I do prefer Craftsman, however, given that I've had el cheapo sockets come apart on me when I need 'em most... I use only 6-point sockets myself for best grippage. My combo wrenches are 12-point, having been purchased before I realized the value of 6-point. It's easier to fit 12-point combo wrenches in tight spaces, anyway. >>I had planned to use ordinary 10w-30 as >>specified by the service manual till others here suggested that the >>chemicals might not be right. Wonder what Honda uses... maybe ordinary >>10w-30! ;-) > > > Well, I have been quite happy with Pennzoil 5W-30 for my car's engine oil, > for all its life. I mean, I notice nothing bad happening from it, at 168k > miles and 14 years. (5W-30 is the weight my owner's manual recommends for my > climate.) Mine too; I was referring to tranny oil. All engine oils are created equal, if they bear that grade stamp I forget the name of just now. For the tranny, on the other hand, there was some discussion here about more or less slippage adversely affecting the synchromesh gear system; hence my caution. > For stuff like this, I've had a lot of luck with either (1) local government > run recycling centers; or (2) hazardous material recycling drives a couple > times a year; and (3) places like Autozone and independent garages taking > the stuff off my hands. The local autoparts place will take motor oil; have to check on the other stuff. I thought I might have seen something about coolant in the sewer here, have to check on that too. > This is similar to the capacity of my 1.5 Liter engine. Your owner's manual, > if you have one, has the exact specs. That number (1.00) is from the Helm manual. > Honda rocks. Yes indeed. My first one. I did enjoy the Pontiac, though, that monster was nearly indestructable. I'm *really* sorry that my Honda bumpers are just about useless and come apart at the slightest serious bump. On the Pontiac, other bumpers were destroyed while merely a few chunks of rust would fall out of mine (was rear-ended once on the highway). |
#6
|
|||
|
|||
Abeness wrote:
> Elle wrote: > >> Just a thought: Maybe the thing won't fail catastrophically any sooner >> than >> the OEM, but it might not regulate temperatures optimally. > > > That wouldn't kill me. I suspect it's close enough. > >> Have another car standing by so you can run to Autozone and buy a 19 mm >> socket (six-faced, not eight-faced, doh, pardon my earlier post-o) as >> needed. :-) > > > Oh, no need for that, there's an autoparts place (Strauss) just a few > blocks away, and anyway I'd try to loosen the plug first--the coolant > doesn't pour out just from cracking it loose, if I got lucky. I do > prefer Craftsman, however, given that I've had el cheapo sockets come > apart on me when I need 'em most... > > I use only 6-point sockets myself for best grippage. My combo wrenches > are 12-point, having been purchased before I realized the value of > 6-point. It's easier to fit 12-point combo wrenches in tight spaces, > anyway. > >>> I had planned to use ordinary 10w-30 as >>> specified by the service manual till others here suggested that the >>> chemicals might not be right. Wonder what Honda uses... maybe ordinary >>> 10w-30! ;-) >> >> >> >> Well, I have been quite happy with Pennzoil 5W-30 for my car's engine >> oil, >> for all its life. I mean, I notice nothing bad happening from it, at 168k >> miles and 14 years. (5W-30 is the weight my owner's manual recommends >> for my >> climate.) > > > Mine too; I was referring to tranny oil. All engine oils are created > equal, if they bear that grade stamp not true abe. sorry. massively different additive packages. different base stocks. all the grade stamp does is spec /minima/. > I forget the name of just now. For > the tranny, on the other hand, there was some discussion here about more > or less slippage adversely affecting the synchromesh gear system; hence > my caution. > >> For stuff like this, I've had a lot of luck with either (1) local >> government >> run recycling centers; or (2) hazardous material recycling drives a >> couple >> times a year; and (3) places like Autozone and independent garages taking >> the stuff off my hands. > > > The local autoparts place will take motor oil; have to check on the > other stuff. I thought I might have seen something about coolant in the > sewer here, have to check on that too. > >> This is similar to the capacity of my 1.5 Liter engine. Your owner's >> manual, >> if you have one, has the exact specs. > > > That number (1.00) is from the Helm manual. > >> Honda rocks. > > > Yes indeed. My first one. I did enjoy the Pontiac, though, that monster > was nearly indestructable. I'm *really* sorry that my Honda bumpers are > just about useless and come apart at the slightest serious bump. On the > Pontiac, other bumpers were destroyed while merely a few chunks of rust > would fall out of mine (was rear-ended once on the highway). |
#7
|
|||
|
|||
jim beam wrote:
>> Mine too; I was referring to tranny oil. All engine oils are created >> equal, if they bear that grade stamp > > > not true abe. sorry. massively different additive packages. different > base stocks. all the grade stamp does is spec /minima/. Really? I've read differently on several occasions, though I can't recall where now. Could you point me to a good discussion of differences between grades (excluding synthetics)? |
#8
|
|||
|
|||
jim beam > wrote in
: > Abeness wrote: >> Mine too; I was referring to tranny oil. All engine oils are created >> equal, if they bear that grade stamp > > not true abe. sorry. massively different additive packages. > different base stocks. all the grade stamp does is spec /minima/. There are several grade stamps. API, MB, ACEA, and ILSAC among them. Not all oils carry all stamps, so there is considerable difference between oils as far as compliance with engine makers' standards. -- TeGGeR® The Unofficial Honda/Acura FAQ www.tegger.com/hondafaq/ |
#9
|
|||
|
|||
"Abeness" > wrote snip but comments noted > >>I had planned to use ordinary 10w-30 as > >>specified by the service manual till others here suggested that the > >>chemicals might not be right. Wonder what Honda uses... maybe ordinary > >>10w-30! ;-) > > Mine too; I was referring to tranny oil. Oh okay. > All engine oils are created > equal, if they bear that grade stamp I forget the name of just now. For > the tranny, on the other hand, there was some discussion here about more > or less slippage adversely affecting the synchromesh gear system; hence > my caution. I'll have to look this up. I've been using Pennzoil 10W-30 (or 40 in the climate where I now live) in my 91 Civic's tranny. The owner's manual doesn't say Honda oil is necessary. I thought it was newer Hondas that had stricter specs on the manual transmission fluid. |
#10
|
|||
|
|||
TeGGeR® wrote:
> jim beam > wrote in > : > > >>Abeness wrote: > > >>>Mine too; I was referring to tranny oil. All engine oils are created >>>equal, if they bear that grade stamp >> >>not true abe. sorry. massively different additive packages. >>different base stocks. all the grade stamp does is spec /minima/. > > > > There are several grade stamps. API, MB, ACEA, and ILSAC among them. > > Not all oils carry all stamps, so there is considerable difference between > oils as far as compliance with engine makers' standards. I'm talking about comparing apples with apples, however, not apples with oranges. Is it not the case that oils bearing the same API grade stamp (sans additives) provide at minimum the same engine protection regardless of whether you buy the brand that's USD $2.50/qt. or the one that's USD $1.00/qt.? Obviously, if you're buying an oil that bears additional stamps that indicate adherence to higher standards or that contains additives that increase protection, we'd be talking about a different beast altogether. Anyway, I suppose that is what Jim indicated: different additive packages lead to different levels of protection. I'm not too worried about it, however: Honda spec'd a minimum grade that you can't even buy anymore the last I looked. |
Thread Tools | |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
Flush Radiator - Opinions | Richard | Saturn | 7 | April 4th 05 04:59 PM |
Need to replace thermo switch and thermostat in 95 Civic | DesignGuy | Honda | 15 | February 17th 05 01:29 AM |
1995 Audi 90 2.8l engine temperature low | Gene Buckwalter | Audi | 12 | December 23rd 04 11:20 PM |
coolant loss from 99 oldsmobile alero with 3.4L | Finite Guy | Technology | 2 | December 21st 04 03:50 AM |
'01 Stratus heater issues | [email protected] | Chrysler | 10 | December 17th 04 12:14 AM |