If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the FAQ by clicking the link above. You may have to register before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below. |
|
|
Thread Tools | Display Modes |
#1
|
|||
|
|||
OBD2 Scanners - Recommendations Wanted
Hey All,
First I'm not a mechanic. I can do filter changes, fluid changes (oil, coolant), brakes - you know basic stuff like that. At one time I could even rebuild a 3 speed nonsynchro 1st gear 65 Mustang trani (never shoulda sold that car) and tune the twin carbs on my 63 Corvair (totalled) but those were probably the pinnacles of my automotive knowledge. We now drive an 01 Nissan Xterra and a 90 Dodge Cummins 3/4 ton 5sp 4x4 (I wish I knew something about working on diesels) and have an old rusting 84 Honda Accord (241k miles and still IMO the most dependable car we own - just looks bad) around for when something else isn't running. Anyway I'm thinking of buying somekind of OBD2 scanner for the Xterra. I don't like paying to clear relatively unimportant service engine soon - light on - codes. As an example - the other day at a store the engine didn't shut down right (never locked the steering and I'm not sure what else (10 below zero F) so the light came on. After that it ran fine and but the SES light was on. Simply IMO a meaningless nuisance code and of course it cost $ to diagnose as meaningless and clear. Anyway I'm looking for recomendations on OBD2 scanners - their pluses and minuses. I've seem em from about $90 to over $200. I'm looking for value for the dollar. So the cheapest may not be adequate but OTOH the most expensive is likely overkill as I'm an occasional "shade tree" mechanic. All opinions welcome! Thanks an Take Care! -Ed- PS - The older I get the more I long for the days when a guy could work on a car on a warm summer night and actually achieve some real performance not just making a car "prettier". |
Ads |
#2
|
|||
|
|||
On 13 Jan 2005 08:59:20 -0800, "EasyEd" >
wrote: >Hey All, > >First I'm not a mechanic. I can do filter changes, fluid changes (oil, >coolant), brakes - you know basic stuff like that. At one time I could >even rebuild a 3 speed nonsynchro 1st gear 65 Mustang trani (never >shoulda sold that car) and tune the twin carbs on my 63 Corvair >(totalled) but those were probably the pinnacles of my automotive >knowledge. We now drive an 01 Nissan Xterra and a 90 Dodge Cummins 3/4 >ton 5sp 4x4 (I wish I knew something about working on diesels) and have >an old rusting 84 Honda Accord (241k miles and still IMO the most >dependable car we own - just looks bad) around for when something else >isn't running. > >Anyway I'm thinking of buying somekind of OBD2 scanner for the Xterra. Hi Ed, Depends on how far you want to go with this. The more expensive the scanner the more you can do with it. If you just want a [code reader], those are relatively cheap and you can get them at any auto parts store. A [scanner] OTOH will look at individual parameters, not just pull codes and reset the MIL. How many parameters? The more you pay, the more capable your hardware and software. I have an Actron 9135, Actron 9145, and a Davis Carchip x/l. The first item is a code reader. And it has I/M monitoring, which is inspection and maintenance mode. The 9145 actually looks at specific individual components and gives you feedback from what the car computer sees. The Davis Carchip is a datalogger and pretty much does what the 9145 does but is plugged in all the time to the OBDII port to record different parameters under dynamic conditions ( while you drive ). The Davis Carchip might be your best buy. It is available at Sears in the tool department, automotive section. Be sure to get the "x/l" model, as it does -way- more than the basic model. Expect to pay $150 + tax for it. It will also reset your MIL if you want it to, and you download it's stored readings through your serial port into the Carchip program that comes in the package. Pretty slick IMO. Good bang for the buck. BTW, if you want the Actron 9135 I have, I'll ship it to you for a fair price. It is in new condition, only used a couple times. Let me know what they are going for on e-bay if you're interested, but I think your best buy is the Davis Carchip. Lg e-mail addy is good >I don't like paying to clear relatively unimportant service engine soon >- light on - codes. As an example - the other day at a store the engine >didn't shut down right (never locked the steering and I'm not sure what >else (10 below zero F) so the light came on. After that it ran fine and >but the SES light was on. Simply IMO a meaningless nuisance code and of >course it cost $ to diagnose as meaningless and clear. > >Anyway I'm looking for recomendations on OBD2 scanners - their pluses >and minuses. I've seem em from about $90 to over $200. I'm looking for >value for the dollar. So the cheapest may not be adequate but OTOH the >most expensive is likely overkill as I'm an occasional "shade tree" >mechanic. All opinions welcome! > >Thanks an Take Care! -Ed- > >PS - The older I get the more I long for the days when a guy could work >on a car on a warm summer night and actually achieve some real >performance not just making a car "prettier". |
#3
|
|||
|
|||
I use this one http://www.obd-2.com/#home It runs on a laptop though. You
can download the software to look at. It has sample data. The nice thing is you can save scans on the computer while driving and analyze later. "EasyEd" > wrote in message oups.com... > Hey All, > > First I'm not a mechanic. I can do filter changes, fluid changes (oil, > coolant), brakes - you know basic stuff like that. At one time I could > even rebuild a 3 speed nonsynchro 1st gear 65 Mustang trani (never > shoulda sold that car) and tune the twin carbs on my 63 Corvair > (totalled) but those were probably the pinnacles of my automotive > knowledge. We now drive an 01 Nissan Xterra and a 90 Dodge Cummins 3/4 > ton 5sp 4x4 (I wish I knew something about working on diesels) and have > an old rusting 84 Honda Accord (241k miles and still IMO the most > dependable car we own - just looks bad) around for when something else > isn't running. > > Anyway I'm thinking of buying somekind of OBD2 scanner for the Xterra. > I don't like paying to clear relatively unimportant service engine soon > - light on - codes. As an example - the other day at a store the engine > didn't shut down right (never locked the steering and I'm not sure what > else (10 below zero F) so the light came on. After that it ran fine and > but the SES light was on. Simply IMO a meaningless nuisance code and of > course it cost $ to diagnose as meaningless and clear. > > Anyway I'm looking for recomendations on OBD2 scanners - their pluses > and minuses. I've seem em from about $90 to over $200. I'm looking for > value for the dollar. So the cheapest may not be adequate but OTOH the > most expensive is likely overkill as I'm an occasional "shade tree" > mechanic. All opinions welcome! > > Thanks an Take Care! -Ed- > > PS - The older I get the more I long for the days when a guy could work > on a car on a warm summer night and actually achieve some real > performance not just making a car "prettier". > |
#4
|
|||
|
|||
On 13 Jan 2005 08:59:20 -0800, "EasyEd" >
wrote: <snip> >Anyway I'm thinking of buying somekind of OBD2 scanner for the Xterra. >I don't like paying to clear relatively unimportant service engine soon >- light on - codes. As an example - the other day at a store the engine >didn't shut down right (never locked the steering and I'm not sure what >else (10 below zero F) so the light came on. After that it ran fine and >but the SES light was on. Simply IMO a meaningless nuisance code and of >course it cost $ to diagnose as meaningless and clear. There are no meaningless codes. > >Anyway I'm looking for recomendations on OBD2 scanners - their pluses >and minuses. I've seem em from about $90 to over $200. I'm looking for >value for the dollar. So the cheapest may not be adequate but OTOH the >most expensive is likely overkill as I'm an occasional "shade tree" >mechanic. All opinions welcome! This is a good start: =46ind them with google. Trucking McCarney Technologies=20 PC Based Guentchev.com=20 OBDII Automotive Diagnostics Homepage=20 ScanTool.net - inexpensive OBD-II scan tools=20 Muliplex Systems, Diagnostic Tools, Monitors and Amplifiers, CAN Controller Area Network Tools,=20 Advanced Vehicle Technologies, Inc.=20 Dearborn Group, Inc. - VSI-VLT=20 ELM Electronics=20 AutoEnginuity - OBD II Scan Tool - Unleash the diagnostics power built into your vehicle=20 Palm Based Generic OBDII Scan Tool for your Palm compatible PDA=20 Auterra OBD II Scan Tool for Palm Home Page=20 Auterra OBD II Scan Tool and Dyno Home Page=20 Handhelds Actron Manufacturing=20 Autocheckup Xray=20 Ferret Instruments Automotive Service Test Equipment=20 GenRad - The Technology of Knowledge=20 Hickok Incorporated - Supplying Technical and Engineering Capabilities Worldwide=20 Snap-on Diagnostics=20 Vetronix Corporation=20 Blue Streak Electronics - Home of the BDM Diagnostic Monitor=20 X431-HOME=20 Import ----- CARSOFT International ---------------=20 Autodiagnos - Diagnostics for Peak Performance=20 Baum Tools Home Page=20 Nextech=20 Automotive Electronics Services Home Page - AES=20 Diagnostic Dialog DTC Lookup=20 BAT Auto Technical Scan Tool info=20 Delphi-Integrated Service Solutions=20 AutoTap OBD-II Diagnostic Scanner Product Information=20 EASE Diagnostics, an award-winning simulation and software design-engineering firm creating adv=20 INTERRO SYSTEMS INC.=20 |
#5
|
|||
|
|||
Hey All,
Thank You for the replies. I see I've a fair bit to look through. I hadn't thought about logging performance data but like the idea. Thanks Again! an Take Care! -Ed- |
#6
|
|||
|
|||
On 15 Jan 2005 08:36:00 -0800, "EasyEd" >
wrote: >Hey All, > >Thank You for the replies. I see I've a fair bit to look through. I >hadn't thought about logging performance data but like the idea. >Thanks Again! an Take Care! -Ed- Good Luck with your purchase whatever it is. I -really- like the logging bit because it can catch stuff that only happens on the highway. The reason I didn't go with Auto-Tap or such is because I don't have a portable computer, otherwise I might have chosen Auto-Tap. But if you do get the Davis Carchip, I would say you did good. Lg |
#7
|
|||
|
|||
I bought one of these (www.scantool.net) from DigiMoto off of eBay. It was
about $80. It connects to my notebook. Considering that the nearest shop to my home want $70 just to find out the error #, and Precision Tune wants $54, I thought it was a deal. This gives good numbers and readings on all of the sensors, etc. There are a few different software apps for the scantool that give a lot of information. Most is free, a couple have a price tag. As time goes by, the software will likely become more advanced. A pretty good investment, I think. Richard "EasyEd" > wrote in message oups.com... > Hey All, > > First I'm not a mechanic. I can do filter changes, fluid changes (oil, > coolant), brakes - you know basic stuff like that. At one time I could > even rebuild a 3 speed nonsynchro 1st gear 65 Mustang trani (never > shoulda sold that car) and tune the twin carbs on my 63 Corvair > (totalled) but those were probably the pinnacles of my automotive > knowledge. We now drive an 01 Nissan Xterra and a 90 Dodge Cummins 3/4 > ton 5sp 4x4 (I wish I knew something about working on diesels) and have > an old rusting 84 Honda Accord (241k miles and still IMO the most > dependable car we own - just looks bad) around for when something else > isn't running. > > Anyway I'm thinking of buying somekind of OBD2 scanner for the Xterra. > I don't like paying to clear relatively unimportant service engine soon > - light on - codes. As an example - the other day at a store the engine > didn't shut down right (never locked the steering and I'm not sure what > else (10 below zero F) so the light came on. After that it ran fine and > but the SES light was on. Simply IMO a meaningless nuisance code and of > course it cost $ to diagnose as meaningless and clear. > > Anyway I'm looking for recomendations on OBD2 scanners - their pluses > and minuses. I've seem em from about $90 to over $200. I'm looking for > value for the dollar. So the cheapest may not be adequate but OTOH the > most expensive is likely overkill as I'm an occasional "shade tree" > mechanic. All opinions welcome! > > Thanks an Take Care! -Ed- > > PS - The older I get the more I long for the days when a guy could work > on a car on a warm summer night and actually achieve some real > performance not just making a car "prettier". > |
Thread Tools | |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
bmw obd2 compatability | Jon | BMW | 1 | November 7th 04 01:05 AM |
Recommendations for very small nible 4x4 chase vehicle... | Mesquito Creek | 4x4 | 28 | July 21st 04 05:30 PM |
Recommendations: UK insurers | John Gallagher | Alfa Romeo | 14 | June 30th 04 03:40 PM |