A Cars forum. AutoBanter

If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the FAQ by clicking the link above. You may have to register before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below.

Go Back   Home » AutoBanter forum » Auto makers » Corvette
Site Map Home Register Authors List Search Today's Posts Mark Forums Read Web Partners

HEI Module



 
 
Thread Tools Display Modes
  #1  
Old July 16th 05, 03:52 AM
daveo76
external usenet poster
 
Posts: n/a
Default HEI Module

I was driving my '76 (L48, 4spd) home today and while accelerating from
a stop it cut out for a moment, and then came back to life. It is
running now, but backfiring a bit through the exhaust, and I can hear a
miss at around 2500 rpm. It was running great before the cut-out.
Judging from other posts I've read here, I think it's the ignition
module. I'm going to start there anyway because it's cheap and easy
and I've not done it in the four years I've had the car. I'll also
probably check the timing and take a look at the wires (I did replace
those and plugs, cap, rotor, etc. recently).

My question: is it worth it to spend the extra $$ for the performance,
after-market modules, or should I just go parts-store OEM? The engine
is basically stock except for a K&N filter and dual Magna-flow exhaust
(no cats).

Also, could these symptoms be caused by a toasted EGR valve - it's
still hooked up. What about the coil? Thanks,

Dave

Ads
  #2  
Old July 16th 05, 02:14 PM
BSAKing
external usenet poster
 
Posts: n/a
Default

I had the same problem - here is some advice I got that may be useful to
you.


>I have a 76 vette and I had to replace the ingintion control module about 3
>years ago - the first time since new.
>
>Now - today it is experiencing the same symptoms - it died on me travelling
>along, let it sit for a bit while I checked it out and then away it went
>again.
>
>When I replaced it, I did liberally apply the silicon grease to the back of
>it. Now - the replacement I got from Canadian Tire (the equivalent of a
>WalWart) and I am wondering if there is something else I should have
>replaced at the same time? Or are control modules all not equal and maybe I
>should have replaced it with one directly from GM?
>
>thanks.

================================================== =============
It is always advisable to change the ignition coil when replacing a module
on an
HEI system. Usually the primary of the coil intermittantly shorts out
causing
damage to the module. Another possibility is your pickup coil. Every time
the
vacuum advance pulls in or releases, the pickup coil leads flex. There is
just
so much flexing a 29 year old pair of wires can take, until the strands give
out. Disconnect the pickup coil, and then put an ohm meter across the pickup
coil leads. Connect a piece of vacuum hose to the vacuum advance and apply
vacuum to the hose. This will make the coil rotate. Watch for any
fluctuation in
the ohm meter indicating broken wires. By doing this, you will also find out
if
your vacuum advance is working.


  #3  
Old July 16th 05, 05:32 PM
Paul H.
external usenet poster
 
Posts: n/a
Default

BSAKing wrote:
> I had the same problem - here is some advice I got that may be useful to
> you.
>
>
>
>>I have a 76 vette and I had to replace the ingintion control module about 3
>>years ago - the first time since new.
>>
>>Now - today it is experiencing the same symptoms - it died on me travelling
>>along, let it sit for a bit while I checked it out and then away it went
>>again.
>>
>>When I replaced it, I did liberally apply the silicon grease to the back of
>>it. Now - the replacement I got from Canadian Tire (the equivalent of a
>>WalWart) and I am wondering if there is something else I should have
>>replaced at the same time? Or are control modules all not equal and maybe I
>>should have replaced it with one directly from GM?
>>
>>thanks.

>
> ================================================== =============
> It is always advisable to change the ignition coil when replacing a module
> on an
> HEI system. Usually the primary of the coil intermittantly shorts out
> causing
> damage to the module. Another possibility is your pickup coil. Every time
> the
> vacuum advance pulls in or releases, the pickup coil leads flex. There is
> just
> so much flexing a 29 year old pair of wires can take, until the strands give
> out. Disconnect the pickup coil, and then put an ohm meter across the pickup
> coil leads. Connect a piece of vacuum hose to the vacuum advance and apply
> vacuum to the hose. This will make the coil rotate. Watch for any
> fluctuation in
> the ohm meter indicating broken wires. By doing this, you will also find out
> if
> your vacuum advance is working.
>
>

Ten years ago I had the same symptoms on a '79 350. Pulled the
distributor and tore it down all the way. Replaced the module--didn't
fix the problem then found the intermittent pick-up coil wire mentioned
above. Also found red, rusty dust that was adding friction to the
advance mechanism. IIRC, the dust was coming from weight pivots on the
drive shaft below the advance plate. Dust was also in the cap/coil
area--maybe causing intermittent cross firing. Replaced the module,
pickup coil & cap. Cleaned the advance system. Used the old coil.
Worked OK after just those things. But now, I'd go along with BSAKing
and spring for a new coil and module.

Check for an oil spiral on the distirbutor shaft. Mine had one and it
was crudded up with little oil flow to lube the bearing.

There are some high-current modules for high current coils but with a
stock or OEM coil, a brand name OEM module should be OK.

Paul H.
  #4  
Old July 16th 05, 09:28 PM
Steve G
external usenet poster
 
Posts: n/a
Default

The module is probably the most often blamed, but seldom the culprit. All
of the failed hei modules I've seen , and I've seen a lot (was a lic tech
working in a busy shop in the 70's and 80's) all acted the same way. They
always totally failed and engine quit. Intermittent problems and rough
running were never found to be traced to a module. Unlike others in this
post, i had never run across one that was toasted due to a bad coil. I've
heard techs blame the coil when they had a second module fail in a short
time, but I think ultimately the failure was traced to absence of heat sink
grease in installation. Shorted coils usually manifest themselves elsewhere
before they would ever burn a module, low secondary voltage resulting in
misfire under load etc.

Broken/breaking wires on the pick-ip coil was a high probability for this
kind of problem. Also, look for a burn mark in the underside centre of the
rotor. If you have a plug(s) or plug wire(s) with high resistance the high
secondary voltage will seek out it's easiest path to ground, often burning a
hole through the centre of the rotor and grounding to the dist shaft. If
you find burning in this spot don't stop there. Now find the cause of the
high secondary resistance, check all the plugs and wires.
In my opinion, not likely the coil, but it is possible. Running it on an
old scope and pulling a plug wire off while running will show max coil
output. If it's within spec keep looking, but again, yank on the pick-up
wires first.

No on the egr. Failed and stuck open would give you an extremely rough
idle and would smooth out at higher rpm. Failed closed and not opening may
not even be noticeable, but can give you ignition "pinging". If you had
previously had to retard the timing from factory settings to get rid of the
ping it may be because of the egr not functioning. Not as prevelant on GM
vehicle, but Ford v8's would ping like crazy when the egr quit functioning.
A good working egr system allows you to run timing advanced quite a bit,
increasing power and decreasing fuel consumption.

If the pick-up is determinded to be the problem, the dist must be removed
and disassembled to replace it. Service all mech advance items and check
the vacuum advance for proper function. I would also check cap, rotor,
plugs and wires while I was at it, good time to do the whole tuneup thing.
Good Luck,
Steve G.



"daveo76" > wrote in message
oups.com...
> I was driving my '76 (L48, 4spd) home today and while accelerating from
> a stop it cut out for a moment, and then came back to life. It is
> running now, but backfiring a bit through the exhaust, and I can hear a
> miss at around 2500 rpm. It was running great before the cut-out.
> Judging from other posts I've read here, I think it's the ignition
> module. I'm going to start there anyway because it's cheap and easy
> and I've not done it in the four years I've had the car. I'll also
> probably check the timing and take a look at the wires (I did replace
> those and plugs, cap, rotor, etc. recently).
>
> My question: is it worth it to spend the extra $$ for the performance,
> after-market modules, or should I just go parts-store OEM? The engine
> is basically stock except for a K&N filter and dual Magna-flow exhaust
> (no cats).
>
> Also, could these symptoms be caused by a toasted EGR valve - it's
> still hooked up. What about the coil? Thanks,
>
> Dave
>



  #5  
Old July 19th 05, 06:24 AM
daveo76
external usenet poster
 
Posts: n/a
Default

Thanks all for your responses. I waited a few days since I just
finished pulling out the dist. I see a lot of that red dust around the
advance mech and also the wires from the pickup are pretty brittle
looking. I am considering now replacing the whole distributor.
Ecklers and others on Ebay have a ~$100 aftermarket HEI - supposedly
equivalent to an Accel. It includes 50K volt coil, cap, rotor and
module. Definitely would be cheaper than replacing all those parts (or
even some) individually. Not sure about the quality, you probably get
what you pay for. If anyone has any experience with this distributor,
let me know. Other options include rebuilding mine (at least with new
pickup coil), a rebuilt OEM (about the same $$, but would have to buy
coil and module seperately), or a name brand aftermarket (Accel,
Mallory, etc. - much more $$).

As an aside, I checked the resistance of the plug wires. They were all
at least in the same order of magnitude, 1K - 3K ohms. Sound OK? It
at least tells me that none of them are cut or burned completely.
(They're really only about a year old, with less than 1K miles). I'm
assuming plugs are OK - replaced at same time with AC Delco's.

Dave

Steve G wrote:
> The module is probably the most often blamed, but seldom the culprit. All
> of the failed hei modules I've seen , and I've seen a lot (was a lic tech
> working in a busy shop in the 70's and 80's) all acted the same way. They
> always totally failed and engine quit. Intermittent problems and rough
> running were never found to be traced to a module. Unlike others in this
> post, i had never run across one that was toasted due to a bad coil. I've
> heard techs blame the coil when they had a second module fail in a short
> time, but I think ultimately the failure was traced to absence of heat sink
> grease in installation. Shorted coils usually manifest themselves elsewhere
> before they would ever burn a module, low secondary voltage resulting in
> misfire under load etc.
>
> Broken/breaking wires on the pick-ip coil was a high probability for this
> kind of problem. Also, look for a burn mark in the underside centre of the
> rotor. If you have a plug(s) or plug wire(s) with high resistance the high
> secondary voltage will seek out it's easiest path to ground, often burning a
> hole through the centre of the rotor and grounding to the dist shaft. If
> you find burning in this spot don't stop there. Now find the cause of the
> high secondary resistance, check all the plugs and wires.
> In my opinion, not likely the coil, but it is possible. Running it on an
> old scope and pulling a plug wire off while running will show max coil
> output. If it's within spec keep looking, but again, yank on the pick-up
> wires first.
>
> No on the egr. Failed and stuck open would give you an extremely rough
> idle and would smooth out at higher rpm. Failed closed and not opening may
> not even be noticeable, but can give you ignition "pinging". If you had
> previously had to retard the timing from factory settings to get rid of the
> ping it may be because of the egr not functioning. Not as prevelant on GM
> vehicle, but Ford v8's would ping like crazy when the egr quit functioning.
> A good working egr system allows you to run timing advanced quite a bit,
> increasing power and decreasing fuel consumption.
>
> If the pick-up is determinded to be the problem, the dist must be removed
> and disassembled to replace it. Service all mech advance items and check
> the vacuum advance for proper function. I would also check cap, rotor,
> plugs and wires while I was at it, good time to do the whole tuneup thing.
> Good Luck,
> Steve G.
>
>
>
> "daveo76" > wrote in message
> oups.com...
> > I was driving my '76 (L48, 4spd) home today and while accelerating from
> > a stop it cut out for a moment, and then came back to life. It is
> > running now, but backfiring a bit through the exhaust, and I can hear a
> > miss at around 2500 rpm. It was running great before the cut-out.
> > Judging from other posts I've read here, I think it's the ignition
> > module. I'm going to start there anyway because it's cheap and easy
> > and I've not done it in the four years I've had the car. I'll also
> > probably check the timing and take a look at the wires (I did replace
> > those and plugs, cap, rotor, etc. recently).
> >
> > My question: is it worth it to spend the extra $$ for the performance,
> > after-market modules, or should I just go parts-store OEM? The engine
> > is basically stock except for a K&N filter and dual Magna-flow exhaust
> > (no cats).
> >
> > Also, could these symptoms be caused by a toasted EGR valve - it's
> > still hooked up. What about the coil? Thanks,
> >
> > Dave
> >


 




Thread Tools
Display Modes

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

vB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
Forum Jump

Similar Threads
Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
rec.autos.makers.chrysler FAQ, Part 1/6 Dr. David Zatz Chrysler 6 December 7th 06 05:55 PM
330 CD (2003) TV MODULE Wendy74 BMW 0 June 10th 05 09:47 PM
rec.autos.makers.chrysler FAQ, Part 3/6 Dr. David Zatz Chrysler 0 April 22nd 05 05:32 AM
rec.autos.makers.chrysler FAQ, Part 1/6 Dr. David Zatz Chrysler 7 February 1st 05 02:43 PM
rec.autos.makers.chrysler FAQ, Part 1/6 Dr. David Zatz Chrysler 10 December 2nd 04 06:19 AM


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 10:53 AM.


Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.6.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2024, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright ©2004-2024 AutoBanter.
The comments are property of their posters.