If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the FAQ by clicking the link above. You may have to register before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below. |
|
|
Thread Tools | Display Modes |
#11
|
|||
|
|||
On 4 Feb 2005 07:10:12 -0500, Bob > wrote:
>Seems kinda strange that both salesperson and service guy would tell me >2005 325xi and X3/X5 AWD was the same... Makes me wonder what else they >said wasn't true... Everything you heard when his mouth was moving ;-) |
Ads |
#12
|
|||
|
|||
"daytripper" > wrote in message ... > On 4 Feb 2005 07:10:12 -0500, Bob > wrote: > >>Seems kinda strange that both salesperson and service guy would tell >>me >>2005 325xi and X3/X5 AWD was the same... Makes me wonder what else >>they >>said wasn't true... > > Everything you heard when his mouth was moving ;-) From his mouth to your ears. ;-) --Fred W |
#13
|
|||
|
|||
Thanks again...
So is the 325xi worth the money? Not a trivial purchase for me and I'm having a hard time deciding... I've read just about everything I could find on the 325 which seems to suggest it is. But just when I convince myself the car is fairly priced for what you get I pick up the paper and see $19k AWD Subaru or Suzuki ads. One big concern is cost of ownership after the 4/50 warranty period. Bob "fbloogyudsr" > wrote in : > "Bob" > wrote >> In the meantime let me run this by you... The whole idea behind my >> interest in a 325xi is as a safe replacement for my wife's FWD Passat >> equipped with Michelin Alpins during the winter. We both really like >> the VW 90% of the time but I'd like something a little better for her >> during some of our pretty bad driving days here in Upstate NY. > > My 330xi has Pilot Alpine's on it! The car is way better in snow than > my wife's Toyota Highlander with all-season Toyo tires, or my T100 > Truck. As long as it doesn't get high-centered, it's almost > unstoppable. It climbs the road to our vacation home (10:1 grade) with > no problems whatever. Directional stability is far better - it > doesn't slew around because the tread grips not only longitudinally > but laterally (which all-season's aren't very good at.) > >> How will the BMW 38/62 AWD system with manual transmission compare to >> FWD in real world use? The 325xi I'm looking at comes with Pirelli >> P6's, will I need to replace them with "winter" tires for snow & ice? > > See above. Although all-season tires are ok in snow (mine came with > Continental Contact all-seasons), the snows are far better. The BMW > system is designed to make the car drive more like a RWD than FWD. > You can kick out the rear end with DSC defeated, and it will kick a > little before the DSC catches it. The combination of snow tires, ADB > and DSC give astonishing acceleration in snow/ice conditions. > > The difference in traction (on snow) between all-seasons and full-on > snows like the Pilot Alpine's is at least the difference between > (performance) all-seasons and "summer" performance tires. I have a > separate set of rims and tires for summer (325i sport package 7.5" > rims with 225/45 Pilot MXM currently.) They add substantial handling > improvements on dry roads, at the cost of a little ride harshness and > noise. > >> (BTW, isn't the DSC system "defeatable" via a dash switch which would >> allow full power to any wheel?) > > Yes, and you should do so if you're climbing steep hills and need full > power. > Evidently, pushing and holding the button for 3-5 seconds defeats the > ADB, too, although I haven't done that. > > Floyd > |
#14
|
|||
|
|||
"Bob" > wrote
> So is the 325xi worth the money? Not a trivial purchase for me and I'm > having a hard time deciding... I've read just about everything I could > find on the 325 which seems to suggest it is. But just when I convince > myself the car is fairly priced for what you get I pick up the paper and > see $19k AWD Subaru or Suzuki ads. One big concern is cost of ownership > after the 4/50 warranty period. Well, *I* think they're worth it; so do almost all other BMW owners. But I've owned them since '78, so you have to take that into account. My experience on maintenance costs is fairly typical, I believe; anything that will go wrong goes wrong in the first couple of years. It's well worth it to join BMWCCA and find the local independent garages; they're substantially less expensive than the dealer, and in general won't try to sell you service you don't need. The one thing to keep in mind is that they are cars, just like any other brand; they won't be perfect, they will have problems. But I don't think they're any more expensive than any other car to maintain. And they age much more gracefully than most other cars. A Subaru WRX is a really good buy, though, for similar or better performance. Doesn't the Passat come with Synchro AWD? Floyd |
#15
|
|||
|
|||
On Fri, 04 Feb 2005 15:32:21 -0500, daytripper
> wrote: >On 4 Feb 2005 07:10:12 -0500, Bob > wrote: > >>Seems kinda strange that both salesperson and service guy would tell me >>2005 325xi and X3/X5 AWD was the same... Makes me wonder what else they >>said wasn't true... > >Everything you heard when his mouth was moving ;-) Heh. I can seem quite aloof to the average car salesman, but I can't help feeling annoyed, while examine the car, that I invariably know more about it than he does. Then there's the inevitable jackass questions: "What are you driving today"? "What do you do for a living?" Umm... What the HELL does any of that have to do with this car that I'm thinking about driving? Do you think we might talk about the CAR? |
#16
|
|||
|
|||
"dizzy" > wrote in message ... > On Fri, 04 Feb 2005 15:32:21 -0500, daytripper > > wrote: > > >On 4 Feb 2005 07:10:12 -0500, Bob > wrote: > > > >>Seems kinda strange that both salesperson and service guy would tell me > >>2005 325xi and X3/X5 AWD was the same... Makes me wonder what else they > >>said wasn't true... > > > >Everything you heard when his mouth was moving ;-) > > Heh. I can seem quite aloof to the average car salesman, but I can't > help feeling annoyed, while examine the car, that I invariably know > more about it than he does. > > Then there's the inevitable jackass questions: "What are you driving > today"? "What do you do for a living?" Umm... What the HELL does > any of that have to do with this car that I'm thinking about driving? > Do you think we might talk about the CAR? Not do ignore your point, there are ulterior motives for both those questions. But the legitimate content is there too. Examples: What you are driving today tells him a) your frame of reference in evaluating a car b) what you may or may not like in a car since you picked this other car previously c) what particular things about this car that he can show you to contrast from your current car and influence your buying decision. d) some things that he can point out about your previous car that you might not like to draw out a discussion that helps him meet your previously unmet needs. What you do for a living tells him e) some of the potential uses the car will be put to f) what sort of diving habits your job might require of you g) if you have special domain knowledge about cars due to your job h) how a car may relate to your visibility or social status in the community or at your workplace i) how the experience of other existing customers is, that do the same job and have selected his products in the past. It also helps build rapport with a potential customer to understand what he does for a living, what he does for fun, and what his family status is, so that you can speak to him on his terms or at least be interested in him and begin to learn what sorts of things might be important to him, so that the dealer can figure out if he is able to provide you with a product that helps meet those needs. Or, you could just consider him a jackass and move on to someone that cares nothing about you, and just talks about the car. -Russ. |
#18
|
|||
|
|||
Bob > wrote:
>Floyd, > >Thanks for all your help, I really appreciate it. I'll see what I can >find in Car & Driver. > >In the meantime let me run this by you... The whole idea behind my >interest in a 325xi is as a safe replacement for my wife's FWD Passat >equipped with Michelin Alpins during the winter. We both really like the >VW 90% of the time but I'd like something a little better for her during >some of our pretty bad driving days here in Upstate NY. > >How will the BMW 38/62 AWD system with manual transmission compare to FWD >in real world use? The 325xi I'm looking at comes with Pirelli P6's, will it will blow any FWD (and RWD) away on snow, like any full-time AWD. the difference is incredible. it makes the snow "go away" - acceleration is almost like in summer. no matter how you push the pedal the steering and handling will stay neutral. this is also the biggest potential problem: braking is not more efficent, it's easy to get too comfortable to drive fast on bad weather and if you're going too fast into a corner you'll hit the woods regardless of AWD, DSC or other acronyms. >I need to replace them with "winter" tires for snow & ice? yes. proper winter tires such as Nokian Hakka's, and not one of those M+S things. >(BTW, isn't the DSC system "defeatable" via a dash switch which would >allow full power to any wheel?) as far as I know, yes. -- harri 525ixT -95 >Thanx again, >Bob > > >"fbloogyudsr" > wrote in : > >> "Bob" > wrote >>> Seems kinda strange that both salesperson and service guy would tell >>> me 2005 325xi and X3/X5 AWD was the same... Makes me wonder what else >>> they said wasn't true... >> >> Yeah, that's the whole problem with salesmen; they'll say anything to >> make a sale. >> >>> Anyhow, assuming you guys are right and 325xi is "original" 38/62 >>> system, what are the Pros & Cons of this approach over XDrive? >> >> The Pros revolve mostly around simplicity. The Automatic Differential >> Braking >> (ADB) is just another mode of ABS that stops spinning wheels, allowing >> the opposite wheel on that axle to get torque. The fixed-split >> planetary gearset >> is light, simple and not likely to break (unlike the Torsen-like >> system it replaced.) >> The Con is that it's not really able to apply full engine power (DSC >> kicks in >> to prevent wheelspin), especially on dry roads which makes it not as >> "performance-oriented" compared to Audi's system. >> >>> Also wondering about things like... If I've got 2 back and 1 front >>> wheel on ice does the remaining traction wheel get "full" (100%) >>> power as needed? >> >> It won't get 100%, since the torque split will prevent that, but it >> will get torque (which Subaru & Audi can't claim.) >> >>> Someplace I can get a better understanding in detail on how these >>> systems work? >> >> Best bet is old Car & Driver issues in the library. >> >> Floyd >> > |
#19
|
|||
|
|||
Bob > wrote:
>Thanks again... > >So is the 325xi worth the money? Not a trivial purchase for me and I'm >having a hard time deciding... I've read just about everything I could >find on the 325 which seems to suggest it is. But just when I convince >myself the car is fairly priced for what you get I pick up the paper and >see $19k AWD Subaru or Suzuki ads. One big concern is cost of ownership Subaru is one of the very few manufacturers who have an excellent full-time 4WD (AWD) system. Most Audis still have the Torsen, which is excellent too, but many of the other VAG offerings (and Volvo) have the Haldex which is *not* full-time AWD (it only delivers torque if the wheels slip). BMW of course has a real AWD system, although the new systems no longer have any differential locks. Don't know about Suzuki, but I'd think they don't really have AWD, but rather something that only switches on when the front wheels slip. That can be nice too, but AWD is much better IMO (it works all the time). The dealers and marketers of course obfuscate this the best they can, Honda talks about 'real-time 4WD' (another non-AWD). Some Haldex systems distribute 1-2% of the torque to rear wheels all the time, which of course mean that they are full-time 4WD, but in practice they are FWD cars until the a front wheel loses the grip. VW rants about saving fuel because the AWD isn't used 99% of the time. Which is silly, since the rear wheels and axles still use gas to rotate. The only real saving is that the transmission system on a non-AWD car can be made much weaker since it's practically never used Some of the small economy SUVs have a rear wheel transmission shaft which are about as thick as a finger. If the decision is between Subaru and BMW, the deciding factor isn't the AWD system. Both are excellent and durable. -- harri 525ixT -95 >after the 4/50 warranty period. > >Bob > > > >"fbloogyudsr" > wrote in : > >> "Bob" > wrote >>> In the meantime let me run this by you... The whole idea behind my >>> interest in a 325xi is as a safe replacement for my wife's FWD Passat >>> equipped with Michelin Alpins during the winter. We both really like >>> the VW 90% of the time but I'd like something a little better for her >>> during some of our pretty bad driving days here in Upstate NY. >> >> My 330xi has Pilot Alpine's on it! The car is way better in snow than >> my wife's Toyota Highlander with all-season Toyo tires, or my T100 >> Truck. As long as it doesn't get high-centered, it's almost >> unstoppable. It climbs the road to our vacation home (10:1 grade) with >> no problems whatever. Directional stability is far better - it >> doesn't slew around because the tread grips not only longitudinally >> but laterally (which all-season's aren't very good at.) >> >>> How will the BMW 38/62 AWD system with manual transmission compare to >>> FWD in real world use? The 325xi I'm looking at comes with Pirelli >>> P6's, will I need to replace them with "winter" tires for snow & ice? >> >> See above. Although all-season tires are ok in snow (mine came with >> Continental Contact all-seasons), the snows are far better. The BMW >> system is designed to make the car drive more like a RWD than FWD. >> You can kick out the rear end with DSC defeated, and it will kick a >> little before the DSC catches it. The combination of snow tires, ADB >> and DSC give astonishing acceleration in snow/ice conditions. >> >> The difference in traction (on snow) between all-seasons and full-on >> snows like the Pilot Alpine's is at least the difference between >> (performance) all-seasons and "summer" performance tires. I have a >> separate set of rims and tires for summer (325i sport package 7.5" >> rims with 225/45 Pilot MXM currently.) They add substantial handling >> improvements on dry roads, at the cost of a little ride harshness and >> noise. >> >>> (BTW, isn't the DSC system "defeatable" via a dash switch which would >>> allow full power to any wheel?) >> >> Yes, and you should do so if you're climbing steep hills and need full >> power. >> Evidently, pushing and holding the button for 3-5 seconds defeats the >> ADB, too, although I haven't done that. >> >> Floyd >> > |
#20
|
|||
|
|||
"fbloogyudsr" > wrote in
: > "Bob" > wrote >> So is the 325xi worth the money? Not a trivial purchase for me and >> I'm having a hard time deciding... I've read just about everything I >> could find on the 325 which seems to suggest it is. But just when I >> convince myself the car is fairly priced for what you get I pick up >> the paper and see $19k AWD Subaru or Suzuki ads. One big concern is >> cost of ownership after the 4/50 warranty period. > > Well, *I* think they're worth it; so do almost all other BMW owners. > But I've owned them since '78, so you have to take that into account. > My experience on maintenance costs is fairly typical, I believe; > anything that will go wrong goes wrong in the first couple of years. > It's well worth it to join BMWCCA and find the local independent > garages; they're substantially less expensive than the dealer, and in > general won't try to sell you service you don't need. > > The one thing to keep in mind is that they are cars, just like any > other brand; they won't be perfect, they will have problems. But I > don't think they're any more expensive than any other car to maintain. > And they age much more gracefully than most other cars. A Subaru > WRX is a really good buy, though, for similar or better performance. > > Doesn't the Passat come with Synchro AWD? > > Floyd The VW Passat does come with a "4Motion" AWD option which I understand to be similar, if not identical, to Audi Quattro. And I did consider another Passat but given the fact that VW is changing 2006 model year style two different dealers in my area tell me that finding a 2005 v6 "4Motion" in a color I like would be almost impossible. Also pricing, MSRP at least, would be very close to a 325xi. |
Thread Tools | |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
bmw 325xi | Marco D'Intino | BMW | 0 | December 26th 04 11:23 PM |
2005 325xi Maintenance Costs? | Bob | BMW | 8 | December 13th 04 01:54 AM |
2004 325XI oil light yellow when ignition turns off | Frank_Del | BMW | 8 | November 19th 04 12:51 AM |
WTB and Info needed: Parts for a 1991 BMW 325Xi | VSAndrew | BMW | 1 | September 29th 04 05:42 AM |