If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the FAQ by clicking the link above. You may have to register before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below. |
|
|
Thread Tools | Display Modes |
#1
|
|||
|
|||
Speaking of emergency vehicles...
Scenario: you're waiting # 1 at a red light, middle lane, other lanes
blocked. Emerg vehicle pulls up behind, lights flashing. Is it legal for you to run the red to allow the EV to pass? |
Ads |
#2
|
|||
|
|||
"John Harlow" > wrote in message ... > Scenario: you're waiting # 1 at a red light, middle lane, other lanes > blocked. Emerg vehicle pulls up behind, lights flashing. > > Is it legal for you to run the red to allow the EV to pass? Yes, run the light (proceed with caution), or pull ahead of traffic in an adjacent lane, just let the EV by. Frequently I see an EV come up behind someone in the left turn last (least lined up) and the EV honks at the car to get out of the way. Yes that may mean entering the intersection on a red light. |
#3
|
|||
|
|||
On Thu, 10 Mar 2005 13:22:44 -0500, John Harlow wrote:
> Scenario: you're waiting # 1 at a red light, middle lane, other lanes > blocked. Emerg vehicle pulls up behind, lights flashing. > > Is it legal for you to run the red to allow the EV to pass? Legal? Maybe. What I would do is pull forward into the left or right lane in front of the car waiting there but not entering the intersection itself. Less of a risk to be T-Boned. Chris |
#4
|
|||
|
|||
"C.H." > wrote in message
news > On Thu, 10 Mar 2005 13:22:44 -0500, John Harlow wrote: > >> Scenario: you're waiting # 1 at a red light, middle lane, other lanes >> blocked. Emerg vehicle pulls up behind, lights flashing. >> >> Is it legal for you to run the red to allow the EV to pass? > > Legal? Maybe. > > What I would do is pull forward into the left or right lane in front of > the car waiting there but not entering the intersection itself. Less of a > risk to be T-Boned. What I've done in this situation (7 lane-wide intersection, I'm in the center lane of my direction) is remained where I was. The EV will likely drive onto the shoulder or median to pass, in which case cars will edge into the adjacent lane to give way. I'll make way for them, but no way am I pulling out into an intersection against the light. Either some bonehead behind me will take the opportunity to blow through the light (and maybe cause a collision with crossing traffic) or I'd risk getting T-boned, another collision. |
#5
|
|||
|
|||
> What I've done in this situation (7 lane-wide intersection, I'm in the
> center lane of my direction) is remained where I was. The EV will > likely drive onto the shoulder or median to pass, in which case cars > will edge into the adjacent lane to give way. In a city there often is no shoulder or median options. Will you just sit there while an ambulance is right behind you blowing the horn? > I'll make way for them, but no way am I pulling out into an > intersection against the light. I have been in several instances where that's the only option. > Either some bonehead behind me will > take the opportunity to blow through the light (and maybe cause a > collision with crossing traffic) or I'd risk getting T-boned, another > collision. If you can't pull into the intersection without risking getting t-boned, then you definitely ought to stay put and let the EV deal with it. |
#6
|
|||
|
|||
"John Harlow" > wrote in message
... >> What I've done in this situation (7 lane-wide intersection, I'm in the >> center lane of my direction) is remained where I was. The EV will >> likely drive onto the shoulder or median to pass, in which case cars >> will edge into the adjacent lane to give way. > > In a city there often is no shoulder or median options. Will you just sit > there while an ambulance is right behind you blowing the horn? That's rare here in Portland--besides, the EV will pull into the empty lanes of oncoming traffic if all four lanes in my direction are blocked. Its lights are on , the siren is blaring, and its horn is honking--I think the oncoming trafic will notice it. If I'm sitting 1st at the light, the EV is several cars behind me at least--nothing I can do about that. If I see cars behind me squeezing over, I'll follow suit--if it's safe for me to do so. >> I'll make way for them, but no way am I pulling out into an >> intersection against the light. > > I have been in several instances where that's the only option. I've yet to experience this scenario. I assume it exists in other cities. Call me lucky. >> Either some bonehead behind me will >> take the opportunity to blow through the light (and maybe cause a >> collision with crossing traffic) or I'd risk getting T-boned, another >> collision. > > If you can't pull into the intersection without risking getting t-boned, > then you definitely ought to stay put and let the EV deal with it. Right. So far, no problems. |
#7
|
|||
|
|||
On Thu, 10 Mar 2005 18:39:46 GMT, "Bill 2" > wrote:
> >"John Harlow" > wrote in message ... >> Scenario: you're waiting # 1 at a red light, middle lane, other lanes >> blocked. Emerg vehicle pulls up behind, lights flashing. >> >> Is it legal for you to run the red to allow the EV to pass? > > >Yes, run the light (proceed with caution), or pull ahead of traffic in an >adjacent lane, just let the EV by. > >Frequently I see an EV come up behind someone in the left turn last (least >lined up) and the EV honks at the car to get out of the way. Yes that may >mean entering the intersection on a red light. Gonna do it at an intersection where there's a red light camera? It'll cost ya, a day's vacation to go to court to try to get the ticket overturned, and it may turn out badly anyway. Dave Head > |
#8
|
|||
|
|||
Emergency Vehicle Code only allows for emergency vehicles to "request"
the right of way. They can not operate without due regard. If they pressure a vehicle into the intersection and there is an accident ---> BOTH the EV operator and the motorist are liable. Failure to yield does not apply to intersections. If an emergency vehicle is honking behind a stopped car, they are clearly overstepping the lee-way allowed by motor vehicle code. My policy, in the event that an intersection is blocked, is to stop the EV 100-200ft. behind the last car, wait for the light to change and NOT "push" people thru. |
#9
|
|||
|
|||
I didn't know about this law, but it does cover the bases of my concerned.
"ParaDygm" > wrote in message oups.com... > Emergency Vehicle Code only allows for emergency vehicles to "request" > the right of way. They can not operate without due regard. If they > pressure a vehicle into the intersection and there is an accident ---> > BOTH the EV operator and the motorist are liable. Failure to yield does > not apply to intersections. > > If an emergency vehicle is honking behind a stopped car, they are > clearly overstepping the lee-way allowed by motor vehicle code. > > My policy, in the event that an intersection is blocked, is to stop the > EV 100-200ft. behind the last car, wait for the light to change and NOT > "push" people thru. > |
#10
|
|||
|
|||
On Thu, 10 Mar 2005 13:22:44 -0500, "John Harlow"
> wrote: >Scenario: you're waiting # 1 at a red light, middle lane, other lanes >blocked. Emerg vehicle pulls up behind, lights flashing. > >Is it legal for you to run the red to allow the EV to pass? > This happened to me a couple weeks ago. I was stopped at a red light in the right lane. Another car was stopped in the left lane next to me, so there was no clear path for the fire truck. I saw a fire truck approaching from behind me, fast, with lights & sirens blaring. It was pretty obvious he was not intending to stop (actually he looked to be moving so fast I feared he could not stop if I failed to move). Fortunately the road I was intersecting with was one-way, so a quick look revealed no traffic coming from that direction. There were some left-turners in the oncoming lane, who had a green light to turn in front of me, but they wisely stopped and gave me and the fire truck enough room to pull through the intersection. Anyway, it all happened quite fast, and caused me no small anxiety. In hindsight it would have been smarter for me to turn right instead of going straight through the intersection, but that would have added miles to my trip, and I didn't think of it until it was over. I think most emergency vehicles here are equipped with strobe devices to trip the lights, but in this case it didn't seem to happen. |
Thread Tools | |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
yielding to emergency vehicles | Cartlon Shew | Driving | 6 | June 12th 05 04:06 AM |
NTSB Wants Black Boxes in Passenger Vehicles | MoPar Man | Chrysler | 62 | January 14th 05 02:44 PM |
Salvage Registration | [email protected] | Technology | 2 | December 30th 04 02:10 AM |