"RichAsianKid" > wrote in message
oups.com...
> Which of the above is the best roadster? What do people think?
>
> Here's a Russian article. Can anyone translate this.
> http://bmw.carclub.ru/articles/allarticles/0000004340/
>
> I'm not sure which one I'd choose. I probably lean towards the Z4 M,
> but Boxster S has probably better handling. Recently Boxster S won vs
> Z4M in a comparo. SLK 55 has nice hardtop but no manual, but has
> presence (read: chicksmobile?) from the front like the SLR. I think all
> are winners. Any thoughts?
>
The article is too long to translate, but here are the pluses and minuses
that they assign to each:

Boxster:
+ for handling, quality, display arrangment
- for lack of comfort

SLK:
+ for comfort, power
- for handling, braking

Z4:

+ for handling, transmission
- for visibility, comfort